Cost of radio spectrum an obstacle to Postive Train Control
WASHINGTON - After a 2008 train collision killed 25 people in California, Congress mandated new safety measures to prevent more high-speed disasters.

WASHINGTON - After a 2008 train collision killed 25 people in California, Congress mandated new safety measures to prevent more high-speed disasters.
But the goal was met with an invisible obstacle: radio spectrum.
Licenses to the airwaves - used for everything from TV to police scanners to space exploration - are critical to the new system, Positive Train Control. But Amtrak and most other passenger rail agencies floundered for years while trying to acquire those licenses, leaving them short of the bandwidth needed to use the new safety systems.
"It's been one of the single most critical challenges for commuter and passenger railroads in large urban areas," said Joe Szabo, the former administrator of the Federal Rail Administration.
Seven years after Congress' mandate, more than half of commuter lines still don't have the radio spectrum they need, according to the American Public Transportation Association.
Most rail lines expect to miss a year-end deadline to activate Positive Train Control the safety system lawmakers wanted.
Passenger rail lines have blamed Congress for failing to set aside the radio spectrum they needed. Congress blamed the Federal Communications Commission. And the FCC said its hands were tied by lawmakers' inaction.
"You have this classic example of the federal government not working together," said Karl Witbeck, a telecommunications engineer who has worked with rail lines.
The radio waves are critical because Positive Train Control relies on them to communicate with trains, and slow or stop them when they reach excessive speeds.
Private rail operators with deeper pockets moved quickly to snap up spectrum. By the time public agencies started buying in dense urban areas, where many rail lines intersect, demand had spiked for the narrow slice of bandwidth they wanted.
"It's kind of like buying real estate - the time you ask the question determines the price, and how many people are asking the question determines the price," said Witbeck, who works for Stantec, a consulting firm. "Anyone that owned spectrum in these areas, they started jacking up their prices . . . it makes it very difficult for a public agency that has fixed capital budgets."
The combination of factors helps explain why Amtrak had the equipment for Positive Train Control on the tracks when Train No. 188 derailed in Port Richmond on May 12, but had not activated the system.
It had closed on the last band of spectrum it needed on the busy Northeast Corridor only on April 15.
Amtrak is actually ahead of most of its peers.
Even freight operators who have met their spectrum needs expect to miss Congress' year-end deadline for implementing Positive Train Control. Other factors have also contributed to delays, including limited budgets, technical challenges, and regulatory hurdles.
But the slog to acquire spectrum is among the top three problems, said the public transportation association's Brian Tynan.
Lawmakers, he said, "made a lot of decisions in that [2008] bill that weren't based in a whole lot of reality."
One exception is Philadelphia-area commuter rail system SEPTA, which acquired the spectrum it needed in 2010 for $480,000, and expects to have the Positive Train Control system running by the Dec. 31 deadline.
Most other rail lines moved far more slowly.
An Amtrak spokeswoman this week acknowledged that purchasing spectrum "proved to be difficult" but noted that the agency still expects to meet the year-end deadline on the Northeast Corridor.
In contrast to the passenger lines, a consortium of deep-pocketed, more nimble private freight operators snapped up spectrum quickly after the 2008 law passed, unilaterally establishing a specific band - 220 MHz - as the industry standard. That left the public agencies to chase whatever spectrum they could find in a similar range, so that the rail lines' systems could communicate where they share tracks.
Amtrak and most other public rail lines waited two years for regulations to be finalized before trying to acquire spectrum.
They appeared to be caught flat-footed.
Amtrak "did not identify spectrum as a risk to PTC implementation, believing that it had several means available for acquiring spectrum," Amtrak's inspector general wrote in 2012, using the acronym for Positive Train Control. "This has proved not to be the case."
Three attempts to buy spectrum between 2010 and 2012 fell apart, the report said.
Public rail agencies complained of limited budgets and competing demands for their safety dollars. They were also slowed by procurement rules that could take six months to a year, a Department of Transportation study said in 2012.
The report, and the one from the inspector general, sent out alarm bells years in advance that rail lines were unlikely to meet the 2015 deadline.
As early as 2010, Szabo asked the FCC to set aside spectrum for publicly funded passenger lines. While public auctions are typically used to distribute spectrum, passenger lines wanted it at no cost. Amtrak wrote the FCC in 2011 that in the name of public safety, "competitive bidding should not be used."
Those who owned spectrum vigorously disagreed.
Warren Havens, a California man who owned some of the targeted bandwidth, urged the FCC not to turn over any privately held spectrum, accusing Amtrak of playing "the safety card" to seek special treatment.
"Simply citing a Congressional Act is not a free pass to get what one wants from the FCC or anyone," Havens wrote the FCC, comparing Amtrak's request to have licenses reassigned to the use of the 9/11 attacks to justify political ends.
Another group of owners wrote that they had spent millions acquiring spectrum. Reassigning it "would constitute an unprecedented and unfair redistribution."
The FCC declared that it couldn't hand commercial spectrum over to the rails unless ordered to by Congress.
But Congress hadn't done so, leaving rail lines to look to the open market.
When Amtrak finally struck a deal late last year for a crucial chunk of bandwidth, it did so with an old adversary: Havens. An Amtrak spokeswoman said a confidentiality agreement bars it from revealing the price.
In the aftermath of the Philadelphia derailment, FCC officials stood behind their decisions.
Congress "did not designate spectrum, a finite resource, for PTC use or make funds available for railroads to acquire access to spectrum," the FCC's chief of wireless telecommunication, Roger Sherman, wrote three days after the crash. A spokesman said the agency tried to help rail lines making deals with private sellers.
But having spectrum wasn't enough to get Positive Train Control up and running.
Freight lines expect to activate the safety system on just 11,400 miles of the mandated 60,000 miles of track by the end of this year, according to the Association of American Railroads, which represents the carriers.
Amtrak still has months of tuning and testing before it can fully implement the new safety system on the Northeast Corridor.
Potential problems with spectrum received little attention when Congress passed the law, a review of hearings and speeches at the time indicates.
"I have no recollection of the spectrum being an issue," Sen. Diane Feinstein (D., Calif.), who pushed for the law, said this week.
She questioned whether the issue has been the mountain rail companies have described, noting that in her state, MetroLink, whose 2008 train crash led to the law, is on pace to have the new safety system in place by year's end. It has a deal to lease some of freight lines' spectrum. It's expected to cost about $40,000 a year, a MetroLink spokesman said.
Some Democrats who back Positive Train Control blame the FCC for moving too slowly to help railroads. Sen. Chuck Schumer (D., N.Y.) called the agency "a laggard" in a press briefing Thursday.
"[The FCC is] an obstacle, not a change agent," said Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D., Conn.), though both senators said things had improved.
Blumenthal paused for a while when asked about the FCC contention that it can't give away bandwidth without Congressional approval.
"If they're right," he finally answered, "then Congress will have to do it."
@JonathanTamari
























