Skip to content

Justice Department gives up on Alaska Senate lawsuit

Mary Peltola ended up winning by more than 4 percentage points, a wide enough margin that Dan S. Sullivan would have lost even if every ballot cast for a lesser-known candidate had gone to him.

Sen. Dan Sullivan and Mary Peltola participate in a debate in Kodiak, Alaska, Sept. 12, 2026. A final batch of votes pushed Peltola, the Democratic former congresswoman, across the threshold to victory against Sen. Dan Sullivan of Alaska late on Tuesday.
Sen. Dan Sullivan and Mary Peltola participate in a debate in Kodiak, Alaska, Sept. 12, 2026. A final batch of votes pushed Peltola, the Democratic former congresswoman, across the threshold to victory against Sen. Dan Sullivan of Alaska late on Tuesday. Read moreKerry Tasker / New York Times

The Trump administration is giving up its bid to block the certification of results in Alaska’s Senate race, abandoning a legal maneuver that threatened to prevent Sen.-elect Mary Peltola, a Democrat, from taking office.

The Justice Department asked a federal court to declare its lawsuit against Alaska moot Thursday, two days after the Associated Press called the competitive race for Peltola.

Democrats helped recruit a second candidate with a name similar to that of the Republican incumbent, Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, the New York Times reported. On President Donald Trump’s order, the Justice Department had argued even before Election Day, and before the Times’ report, that Alaska should not certify a narrow victory for Peltola until it could be determined that her win was not because of voter confusion.

But critics called the move legally meritless, and lawyers for the state of Alaska, where Republicans control the governorship and the Legislature, sought to have the case dismissed.

Peltola ended up winning by more than 4 percentage points, a wide enough margin that Sullivan would still have lost even if every ballot cast for the lesser-known candidate had gone to him.

In a court filing Thursday, the Justice Department maintained that its initial bid had merit, but it conceded that it would be impossible for its lawyers to interrogate voters about their reasoning now that ballots had been de-identified. Lawyers for the Justice Department “reluctantly” acknowledged that “there no longer exists any means” to figure out whether voters for the potential spoiler, Dan J. Sullivan, meant to pick the incumbent senator instead, and therefore no way to vindicate its claims.

A judge denied the Trump administration’s request to segregate ballots cast for Dan J. Sullivan before the election, but the Justice Department appealed.

The judge could still rule on the merits of the case, even though the Justice Department argues the point is moot.

In October, the Justice Department announced it was investigating Democrats who recruited a decoy Alaska Senate candidate over potential illegal activity. Thursday’s filings did not address the status of that inquiry, which prosecutors acknowledged might never yield criminal charges.

The Justice Department sent letters to 20 Democrats informing them that they might be targets or asking them to preserve their records, and issued hundreds of subpoenas, according to a person familiar with the investigation who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss an ongoing investigation.

Peltola has claimed she was unaware of the plan to recruit a spoiler.

Dan S. Sullivan’s campaign did not immediately respond to a request for comment. In a statement responding to Thursday’s filing, Peltola said that “voters sent a very clear message about the direction they want our state to go in” and added that she was eager to “get to work on behalf of all Alaskans.”

“For Alaskans, there is only one direction: forward,” she said.

This article originally appeared in the New York Times.