Skip to content

Family members of collapse victims testify

CITY TREASURER Nancy Winkler remembered the precious hours she spent on June 5, 2013, with her daughter before the 24-year-old was killed in the collapse of a Salvation Army thrift store.

CITY TREASURER Nancy Winkler remembered the precious hours she spent on June 5, 2013, with her daughter before the 24-year-old was killed in the collapse of a Salvation Army thrift store.

Winkler told a Common Pleas jury Friday that she had just returned home on a flight that morning from California. About 6:30 a.m., her daughter, Anne Bryan, asked her to go for a bike ride.

"It was a beautiful morning," Winkler solemnly said.

Even though the mother didn't get any sleep, she said she went with her daughter for a bike ride.

After they returned home and Anne got ready for the day, Anne "showed me a secondhand shirt she had just bought," Winkler said. "It looked good on her."

Winkler said her daughter was "excited for the day" because she and a friend, Mary Simpson, also 24, were going to shop at secondhand stores and donate clothes.

It was later that morning, when Winkler was in her office, that she learned the Salvation Army store had collapsed. She turned on the TV and watched the news.

Winkler was the last prosecution witness to testify in the trial of Griffin Campbell, 51, charged with third-degree murder and related offenses in the building collapse, at 22nd and Market streets in Center City, that killed six people and injured 13 others.

Anne Bryan and Simpson were two of the six people killed when the store collapsed after an unsupported, three-story wall of a building being demolished next to the thrift store fell onto the store at 10:42 a.m. June 5, 2013.

Maggie Davis, whose husband Borbor Davis, 68, a Liberian immigrant who worked at the thrift store and was also killed, testified Friday that after she learned of the collapse, she frantically helped in the search for her husband, whom she knew was in the store's basement.

At the moment the three-story wall of the building collapsed onto the thrift store, anything could have triggered it, David Peraza, a New York-based engineer at the firm Exponent, said Friday.

The wall "was balanced on its edge," he said. It was "like taking a nickel or a dime and balancing it on its edge. You can do it, but . . .," he said, his voice trailing off.

Campbell was the general contractor on the job to demolish the four-story building next to the one-story thrift store. Peraza testified that as the demolition contractor, it was Campbell's job to decide how the building was to be demolished.

Peraza, looking at a screenshot of a video taken at 9:30 a.m. June 5, 2013, of the demolition testified there were "a lot of areas in an extremely dangerous condition."

The back of the four-story building, which had yet to be fully demolished, was sagging at the top. Columns were missing or "severely tilted," he said. Joists, the horizontal beams that kept the walls stable, were removed. The front facade, which had also supported the walls, had been demolished.

And the three-story wall next to the Salvation Army was unsupported, he said. "This structure at this point in time is in danger of collapse," he testified.

A turning point in the demolition came on June 2, 2013, Peraza said, when there was a switch from demolishing the building by hand to mechanical demolition. It was on that Sunday, when the thrift store was closed, that an excavator was first used to mechanically demolish the building.

With the excavator in use, demolishing the front facade of the building, the "demolition is not being done top-down, it's being done front-back," Peraza said under questioning by Jennifer Selber, the D.A.'s homicide chief.

Not only was mechanical demolition unsafe in an urban setting, but demolishing a building from front to back rather than from top to bottom was unsafe, he said.

Peraza, looking at a photo of the demolition site taken about 6 p.m. June 4, said the building then was in "a very dangerous situation."

He said the shared wall with the thrift store was "freestanding and at least three stories high," with no joists to support it.

"At this time, a disturbance could cause the wall to collapse - a light wind or anything could cause this wall to collapse," he said.

In a written report, Peraza had concluded that it is not possible to determine with any degree of engineering certainty precisely what triggered the collapse - because at that point, anything could have, he said.

On Thursday, Sean Benschop, 45, the operator of the excavator, testified that he was hired and ordered by Campbell to demolish the front and eastern walls of the four-story building.

The eastern wall was farther from the thrift store. The western wall was next to the store.

At the time of the collapse, Benschop said he had a steel beam in the claw of his excavator and was using the beam to poke at the eastern wall of the building in an effort to demolish it.

He said when he hit the eastern wall with the beam, instead of the wall falling away from the building, into a vacant lot, it fell inward, toward the remaining part of the building.

Benschop said the caving in of the eastern wall caused the building to knock over the three-story unsupported western wall, which collapsed onto the thrift store.

In July, Benschop pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter and related offenses.

Campbell is expected to testify in his own defense Tuesday, after the Columbus Day holiday.

On Twitter: @julieshawphilly