Skip to content

Plymouth Whitemarsh High mourns student killed in hit-and-run

Clustered in small groups, their grief palpable, Plymouth Whitemarsh High School students offered remembrances of Denise Cotteta, a talented senior athlete who loved the color lavender.

Suzanne McMonagle and Brianna DePaul, from left, mourn Denise Cotteta, right, who was fatally struck by a car while trying to cross the road at Plymouth Whitemarsh High School. (Akirwa Suwa, staff / Facebook page)
Suzanne McMonagle and Brianna DePaul, from left, mourn Denise Cotteta, right, who was fatally struck by a car while trying to cross the road at Plymouth Whitemarsh High School. (Akirwa Suwa, staff / Facebook page)Read more

Clustered in small groups, their grief palpable, Plymouth Whitemarsh High School students yesterday offered remembrances of Denise Cotteta, a talented senior athlete who loved the color lavender.

Cotteta, 17, who friends say planned to attend Pennsylvania State University, was killed by a car after she stepped into the roadway late Sunday across from the high school in Plymouth Meeting, just one day after the boys' basketball team won a state championship.

"Everybody is really upset," said Brittini Frisby, a 17-year-old junior. "We got off for spring break on Friday, the boys won on Saturday, and on Sunday, this happens. Life is a lot shorter than we think."

Authorities have questioned the driver of a car that was identified by a friend of Cotteta's shortly after the 11:30 p.m. accident. The driver, a woman, is cooperating with police, Montgomery County District Attorney Risa Vetri Ferman said at a news conference yesterday.

No charges have been filed. The woman was released pending the results of the police investigation, Ferman said.

Asked if alcohol was involved, Ferman said that was a possibility. The results of blood-alcohol tests are pending, the district attorney said.

Ferman declined to discuss details of Cotteta's activities before the accident, saying they are part of the investigation.

David Sherman, community relations coordinator for the Colonial School District, said he believed Cotteta had attended the championship game at Penn State.

Sunday, the school held a welcome-back rally to greet the basketball team, but Sherman did not know whether Cotteta had attended. In the contest, Plymouth Whitemarsh defeated Penn Wood High School in the PIAA Class AAAA boys' basketball championship tournament.

Students gathered yesterday around a memorial of flowers, stuffed animals, and candles at the accident site. While students are on a one-week spring break and are not due to return to school until Monday, many came to pay their respects.

In the afternoon, the high school held a memorial gathering that was attended by Cotteta's family and an area minister, Sherman said. At least 100 students attended the gathering, which included speeches by the family.

"She had the most beautiful personality and the best charm," Suzanne McMonagle said as she stood and cried near the memorial.

Other students recalled a happy teen full of life. Cotteta, said Kelsey Raucher, 17, a junior, was such a fan of hot dogs that "she could eat five at one time."

Sherman described Cotteta as "universally liked" by the student body. The district provided counseling to students yesterday and will continue to offer the sessions from noon to 4 p.m. today.

Cotteta played field hockey and lacrosse, and was a member of her class steering committee. She worked part-time at the Greater Plymouth Community Center, where she helped with children's birthday parties. She was considering studying physical therapy, friends said.

"Our thoughts and prayers are with Denise, her family and her extended Colonial School District family," a statement from the district read.

"Yesterday, we were jubilant. Today, we mourn the fact that a wonderful young woman was taken from us far too soon."

Contact staff writer Kristin E. Holmes at 610-313-8211 or kholmes@phillynews.com.