Pa. Supreme Court upholds Bedminster's plan to preserve farmland
In a "significant" ruling, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has upheld a rural Bucks County township's plan to preserve farmland and clarified zoning parameters for towns across the state, lawyers said Monday.
In a "significant" ruling, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has upheld a rural Bucks County township's plan to preserve farmland and clarified zoning parameters for towns across the state, lawyers said Monday.
The 7-0 ruling, issued last week, ends a nine-year battle between Bedminster Township and the Piper Group over a plan to build about 350 single-family houses on 400 acres of farmland.
The ruling's broader effect is to provide a blueprint for "how restrictive agricultural preservation zoning can be" and how towns can fix such laws that are ruled too restrictive, John Rice, the lawyer representing Bedminster, said Monday.
"The elected officials are extremely happy," Rice said. "The ruling draws together other decisions and clears up unanswered questions."
The case goes back to Nov. 1, 2002, when the state Supreme Court ruled that the lot-size and building-density provisions of Bedminster's Agricultural Preservation District were too restrictive. Two weeks later, the township declared its law invalid and proposed changes that decreased the minimum lot size from one acre to less than three-quarters of an acre.
But before the township proposed its changes - called a curative amendment - the Piper Group proposed its own fix: to build 350 homes in that district on lots of about one-seventh of an acre.
"The township covers 30 square miles and has about 6,000 people. It's extremely rural," Rice said. "They proposed building sewage-treatment and public-water plants where there weren't any. It's a difficult situation to have those types of facilities all over and not planned."
In March 2007, after 54 hearings on Piper Group's plans, the township supervisors rejected them, citing their revised law. During the years of hearings, the supervisors negotiated a settlement with C&M Developers, the original challenger to Bedminster's ordinance, to build 220 single-family homes on 400 acres next to a high-density district, Rice said.
Piper Group challenged the township's ruling in Bucks County Court and Commonwealth Court before arguing before the state Supreme Court in May.
The Supreme Court justices "agreed with the township's final results, though they didn't agree with all of the township's reasons," Rice said.
While Rice represented the township from the beginning, Michael Sklaroff of the Philadelphia law firm Ballard Spahr argued the township's case before the Supreme Court.
"The ruling explains clearly for the first time provisions of the Municipalities Planning Code, which governs all zoning outside Philadelphia and Pittsburgh," Sklaroff said Monday, "and what happens when a challenge seeks specific relief.
"It demonstrates that after there's a challenge, the municipality has the opportunity to cure the ordinance by removing things that are unconstitutional," Sklaroff said.
Piper Group's attorney, Robert W. Gundlach Jr. of Fox Rothschild in Warrington, did not return a phone message.
























