Skip to content

Camden mayor, city officials are demanding ouster of Schools Superintendent Alfonso Llano

Alfonso Llano became the state-appointed Camden schools superintendent in December. His predecessor stepped down in July 2025 after clashing with city officials.

State School Superintendent Alfonso Q. Llano Jr. was appointed in January.
State School Superintendent Alfonso Q. Llano Jr. was appointed in January.Read moreElizabeth Robertson / Staff Photographer

Camden Mayor Victor Carstarphen and the city’s top elected officials are calling on Gov. Mikie Sherrill to remove the city’s state-appointed school superintendent.

In a letter dated Nov. 10 to Sherrill and state Education Commissioner Lily Laux, they cite a “serious concern” made by schools chief Alfonso Q. Llano Jr. that “have eroded our confidence” in his ability to lead the troubled district.

The letter, obtained by The Inquirer, lists a series of grievances against Llano since he was appointed by the state in January. Among the complaints, Llano recently notified One Camden Inc., a citywide public school enrollment system, that it plans to withdraw district schools, according to the letter.

“Unfortunately, this is not an isolated decision,” the letter said. “Since taking office, the superintendent has made a series of consequential decisions with limited stakeholder engagement, insufficient planning and significant implications for students and families.”

Llano did not respond to a request seeking comment Monday.

In a statement, district spokeswoman Sheena Yera said Llano “remains focused on the work of moving the Camden City School District forward, improving student outcomes, strengthening accountability, and ensuring that the needs of Camden’s students and families remain at the center of every decision. The superintendent respects the right of elected officials and community stakeholders to express their views.”

The letter demanding Llano’s removal sent shock waves through Camden education circles Monday. Llano was highly praised by the mayor when he became superintendent a few months ago, the first Hispanic to hold the job.

“I am not in agreement with asking him to resign at this juncture,” said former school board member Jose E. Delgado. “I disagree with him on many issues, but I don’t know if asking him to resign is the next step.”

A former school superintendent in Vineland, Llano was tapped by the state 10 months ago to run the Camden school district after a national search. He started the job March 1. He has a three-year contract and gets $260,000 annually.

He replaced another embattled superintendent, Katrina T. McCombs, whose contract was not renewed after a group of city leaders, including Carstarphen, called for her removal. The group said Camden schools needed “a new vision for leadership.”

Since taking over in Camden, Llano has made some moves that were met with opposition and protests. His attempt to consolidate the district’s four magnet schools met with pushback.

The letter also cited Llano’s decision ending a longstanding uniform requirement at the high schools, implementing instead a dress code policy. School start times were also changed, giving families little notice to prepare, the letter said.

» READ MORE: Camden school district sends layoff notices to 100 employees, including entire central office

In addition to the mayor, the letter was signed by the city’s legislative delegation including State Sen. Nilsa Cruz-Perez, and Assemblymen William Spearman and William Moen. City Council President Angel Fuentes, Vice President Arthur Barclay, and former Mayor Dana L. Redd also signed the letter.

The letter was written on letterhead with logos for the city and the Camden Education Fund. In a statement, Giana Campbell, president of the Education Fund, said her group was committed to working with local and state leaders “to protect Camden’s progress and ensure the best possible outcomes for students and families.”

A Sherrill spokeswoman referred comment to the state Department of Education.

Laux’s spokeswoman, Cecelia Williams said in a statement: “The Department remains focused on ensuring Camden students are safe, supported and successful. We take concerns raised by members of the community seriously, and the Commissioner is actively engaging with district leadership and local stakeholders to discuss those concerns.”

The One Camden enrollment system has become a hot debate in recent years as the education landscape has shifted. It is operated by a nonprofit that lets students apply to nearly any public school in the city with one application, ranking their choices and receiving an offer.

Supporters say the process, which began more than a decade ago, is intended to level the playing field for families in a city where more attend schools operated by Renaissance and charter schools than the traditional public school system.

According to its website, parents can still enroll their children directly in their neighborhood school without an application or lottery.

One Camden has had an annual contract with the district since 2014, said executive director Tameeka Mason. Llano issued a notice of termination Oct. 30, which she called a “misinformed policy decision.“

Mason cited possible legal ramifications and declined further comment.

Critics like Delgado and others say the enrollment system has undermined traditional public schools as thousands of students have left to attend charter and Renaissance schools — taking millions of dollars in funding with them.

“Follow the money,” Delgado said.

Enrollment in the traditional public schools has dropped nearly 50%, from 11,660 students in 2013-14 to about 5,300 currently. Payments to charter and Renaissance schools during that period have increased also, from $54.9 million to $198 million.

Activist Vida Neil applauded Llano for moving to cut ties with One Camden. She believes it is “devouring” the traditional school system.

“He’s not giving away any more kids,” Neil said. “We’re making moves to get our kids back.”