Skip to content

PUC approves Pa. American's $195M takeover of Scranton sewer system

State utility regulators on Thursday approved Pennsylvania American Water's $195 million acquisition of the Scranton Sewer Authority's system, despite concerns that the sale amounts to a bailout of the city's troubled sewer system on the backs of the company's existing customer base.

By a 4-1 vote, the Public Utility Commission approved the Scranton system's sale to Pennsylvania American, a subsidiary of American Water of Voorhees. Pennsylvania American serves more than 650,000 customers across the state, including residents in about three dozen municipalities in suburban Philadelphia.

Critics say Pennsylvania American's broader customer base will pick up Scranton's costs to comply with a 2013 consent decree that requires it to fix its combined sewer system, which allows untreated wastewater to flush into waterways during storm events. The compliance costs are estimated at $140 million over 25 years.

The proposal drew formal protests from the Pennsylvania Office of Consumer Advocate, the Pennsylvania Office of Small Business Advocate, and the PUC's Bureau of Investigation and Enforcement. In August, two administrative law judges recommended that the acquisition be denied.

PUC vice chairman Andrew G. Place, the sole dissenting commissioner, said that Pennsylvania American's current customers will be called upon to absorb the transaction costs, and that the sale "is clearly inimical for the existing customer base."

But Commissioners Robert F. Powelson and David W. Sweet, in a joint motion, said it was premature to argue who would pick up the costs until Pennsylvania American filed a formal rate-increase request. "Disputes over the future rates are not ripe for our decision here this morning," they said.

The sale agreement provides for Scranton's 31,000 wastewater customers to continue paying current rates until 2018.

Pennsylvania American, which already provides water service in Scranton, estimated that customers would save $350 million over the next 30 years, or about $7,600 per household. The City of Scranton and the Borough of Dunmore will divide the $125 million in proceeds from the sale after $70 million in debt is retired.

The acquisition requires approval of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the state Department of Environmental Protection, the Justice Department, and the federal court that approved the consent decree.

"Although some steps in the process are taking longer than originally anticipated, we remain confident that Pennsylvania American Water will receive all the necessary approvals, close the acquisition, and begin providing quality wastewater service to Scranton and Dunmore before the end of 2016," the company said in a statement Thursday.

Pennsylvania American is the largest water and wastewater service provider in the state. Its customers include residents of Yardley and Lower Makefield and Falls Townships in Bucks County, Coatesville, and 16 other municipalities in Chester County, and Bridgeport, Norristown and Royersford, and 13 townships in Montgomery County.