Skip to content

Exton Square Mall’s revival as a mixed-use complex gets a judge’s OK. But the fight continues.

West Whiteland Township Supervisors say they plan to appeal a Chester County judge's decision to approve Abrams Realty & Development's proposed redevelopment of the closed mall.

The entrance to the Exton Square Mall, with new apartments in the background, as pictured in 2022. Abrams Realty & Development can now proceed with its redevelopment plans for the site after a judge's order reversing township officials' denial.
The entrance to the Exton Square Mall, with new apartments in the background, as pictured in 2022. Abrams Realty & Development can now proceed with its redevelopment plans for the site after a judge's order reversing township officials' denial.Read moreTOM GRALISH / Staff Photographer

After a year in redevelopment limbo, plans for the dead Exton Square Mall have received a legal stamp of approval. But the fight between developers and local officials is set to continue.

A Chester County judge on Friday ruled in favor of the site’s owner, Abrams Realty & Development, which wants to knock down the enclosed mall and build a mixed-use complex with apartments, shops, and restaurants.

Last fall, West Whiteland Township Supervisors Brian Dunn and Rajesh Kumbhardare rejected those plans, citing sewer, traffic, and density concerns. Their denial prompted Abrams to sue the supervisors, arguing that the plan meets the township’s zoning requirements and should be approved.

» READ MORE: Philly-area malls aren't dead yet. But they are changing.

Chester County Court of Common Pleas Judge Sarah B. Black agreed with Abrams in her order, writing that it appeared the supervisors held Abrams to a “higher standard due to fears of overdevelopment.”

Black reversed the supervisors’ decision, according to the order, and approved Abrams’ application.

Abrams, Black wrote, provided “sufficient evidence to obtain the presumption that the use was consistent with the public health, safety, and welfare of the township.”

But the judge’s decision may not be the last word.

“The township is pursuing all its legal options, and the board intends to appeal the decision,” said Dunn, chair of the West Whiteland Township Supervisors.

“I will not hesitate to stand up and fight for our community when I believe a decision does not serve its best interests,” added Kumbhardare, the board’s vice chair.

Meanwhile, Peter Abrams, CEO of Abrams Realty & Development, said Monday that his company plans to start demolishing the mall by early summer.

The nearly 1 million-square-foot center closed this summer after 53 years in business. The complex, Chester County’s only enclosed mall, had been languishing for years.

Once a bustling shopping destination with more than 100 stores, the center had only a handful of tenants when it shuttered in June.

» READ MORE: How Boscov’s survives in the shadows of so many dead malls

Elkins Park-based Abrams Realty & Development, which last year bought the mall from PREIT for more than $34 million, wants to bring hundreds of townhouses, rental apartments, a 55+ community, and a town center with shops, restaurants, medical offices, and green space.

The property’s 178,000-square-foot Boscov’s would remain, as has been the case at many reimagined malls across the region. The Main Line Health offices and Round 1 entertainment venue would also stay open.

The mall site, located at the intersection of busy Route 100 and Business Route 30, has already been partially redeveloped amid rising demand for high-end apartments.

In recent years, the Point at Exton was constructed on four acres of former mall property. The apartment complex, where units start around $1,700 a month, sits across the street from a Whole Foods, which opened in 2017 in the mall’s former Kmart.

Abrams has said he envisions connecting the existing apartments and the Whole Foods to his project, which would include 172 townhouses, 381 apartments, and 165 “age-restricted active adult apartments.”

The developer also has said he’d build nearly 170,000 square feet of new shops, restaurants, and other commercial space, along with 120,000 square feet of fitness and entertainment venues.

Exton Square Mall is one of several former Philly-area malls with uncertain futures.

In Bucks County, Neshaminy Mall closed on Halloween. Bensalem Township Mayor Joe DiGirolamo has said its owner, Paramount Realty, plans to tear it down, but Paramount has been hush about its intentions.

Facing more uncertainty is Northeast Philly’s Franklin Mall, formerly Franklin Mills, which is no longer for sale after real estate magnate Dean Adler’s ambitious redevelopment plan fell through.

And in South Jersey earlier this month, a developer who wanted to turn Voorhees’ long-dead Echelon Mall into a “regional destination” said he had to pull out because his company, Hoboken Brownstone, could not acquire a $90 million state tax credit. Local officials have been trying to revive the property for nearly two decades.