Skip to content

Philadelphia mother, boyfriend convicted of killing her 4-year-old son, dumping his body in a duffel bag

Dominique Bailey and Kevin Spencer were also convicted of conspiracy, abuse of a corpse, and related crimes.

Prosecutors say Damari Carter, 4, was killed by his mother and her boyfriend in December 2023.
Prosecutors say Damari Carter, 4, was killed by his mother and her boyfriend in December 2023.Read moreCourtesy of AIDBIPOC.org

A West Philadelphia woman and her boyfriend were convicted Monday of third-degree murder in the death of her 4-year-old son, whose body was found inside a duffel bag.

Dominique Bailey, 31, and Kevin Spencer, 33, were also convicted of conspiracy, abuse of a corpse, false reporting of a crime, and related offenses, after a jury heard evidence that the couple had told relatives and police the boy had been fatally struck by a car in December 2023.

But investigators found no evidence to support that, prosecutors said. Instead, they said, Spencer beat Damari Carter to death, then dumped his body in a trash-strewn alleyway in West Philadelphia. Bailey helped to cover up the killing, and had allowed Spencer to abuse her son, prosecutors said.

Bailey and Carter came to Philadelphia in early 2023, according to authorities, and later moved from her father’s West Philadelphia home into Spencer’s Mantua apartment. At the couple’s trial, a neighbor testified she had heard what sounded like a child being beaten and notified the city’s Department of Human Services in December.

No one from the agency appears to have intervened, prosecutors said.

Bailey wanted to get rid of her son so she could start a new family with Spencer, they said, and that evidence including videos from Spencer’s cell phone and audio recordings captured by a neighbor showed Spencer routinely abused Carter, who was nonverbal, but otherwise “perfectly healthy,” Assistant District Attorney John Paul Bezerra said at a news conference Tuesday.

A surveillance camera in the building’s hallway last captured the boy on the night of Dec. 5, 2023, as Spencer carried him into the apartment, prosecutors said. The camera kept recording through December, but Carter never appeared on it again.

On Dec. 7, 2023, prosecutors said, Spencer sent Bailey a video in which Carter, his forehead bruised, sat unresponsive as Spencer smacked him and ordered him to eat a bowl of oatmeal.

That afternoon — after Spencer texted her “don’t let nobody know any moves you making” — Bailey returned from her father’s house with a bag filled with her son’s clothing, prosecutors said. But when detectives searched the apartment weeks later, they found no toys or clothing, a detective testified, and prosecutors contended that Bailey had gathered the boy’s belongings to get rid of them.

And on Dec. 9, 2023, surveillance camera footage captured Spencer leaving the Reno Street apartment with a black duffel bag over his shoulder — the same bag in which the boy’s remains were later found, prosecutors said.

Carter was wearing the same clothes he had on in the Dec. 7 video: maroon sweatpants with “touchdown” printed down the leg and a basketball sweatshirt.

The couple was arrested in January 2024 and charged with the killing. That March, city workers found the duffel bag in the alleyway about a half mile from Spencer’s apartment, with the body inside. The city’s chief medical examiner, Lindsay Simon, concluded that Carter died of “homicidal violence,” and found bleeding beneath the skin of Carter’s scalp, neck, lower back, and legs, according to a summary of her exam.

“Contrary to the way that the defendants treated him, he [Carter] was loved, and he was seen as a precious individual — someone who was worthy of far greater respect than he was ultimately given,” Assistant District Attorney Jon Michael Babineau said at the news conference.

Spencer’s attorney, Michael McDermott, said in an interview Tuesday that “nobody saw either of them [Bailey and Spencer] beating the child.” He also contended that the downstairs neighbor could not say what was happening in the apartment above her. The judge allowed her testimony over his objections, he said.

Still, McDermott said that he was not surprised by the verdict. “It wasn’t an easy case to defend,” he said, “and there was a lot of evidence against them.” Spencer has asked him to appeal, he added.

Bailey’s attorney, Angelo Cameron, was not immediately available for comment.

In pretrial filings, Cameron argued that Bailey was not present when her son died and learned of his death only afterward. He noted that the downstairs neighbor testified that most of the noises she heard came in the mornings, after Bailey had left for work, and that she never heard Bailey hit the boy.

Bailey’s shifting accounts of her son’s death reflected confusion, not an effort to deceive police, he said, and her trips to her father’s house for the boy’s clothing showed concern for his well-being.

Both lawyers had asked that their clients be tried separately — requests that Common Pleas Court Judge Roxanne Covington denied.

Bailey and Spencer are scheduled to be sentenced in December.