Skip to content

Sheriff Bilal has never needed a court ruling to show her contempt | Mike Newall

Plus, the horrid winter of 1776.

Sheriff Rochelle Bilal steps uo to testify in City Council before during annual budget hearing Tuesday, April 28, 2026.
Sheriff Rochelle Bilal steps uo to testify in City Council before during annual budget hearing Tuesday, April 28, 2026.Read moreTom Gralish / Staff Photographer

Every Sunday, Mike Newall brings you an inside look at a story defining Philly this week and a preview of what’s coming in the week ahead.

It may take another week before a city judge decides whether to hold Philadelphia Sheriff Rochelle Bilal’s office in contempt of court.

The sheriff, meanwhile, has never needed a court ruling to show her contempt for the people of Philadelphia.

Common Pleas Court Judge Paula Patrick could push a decision on Bilal until after Thanksgiving. And it’s understandable that she might want a turkey break, given the enormity of her task: trying to make sense of a Gordian knot of a municipal office where even the most basic paperwork seems to be a mystery.

If (alleged) neglect were a public service, Bilal might be Philadelphia’s most dedicated civil servant. There is something almost impressive about it.

Bilal’s disastrous handling of a decidedly unglamorous arm of city government is nothing if not comprehensive. The mission is straightforward: Guard the courts. Transfer prisoners. Oversee property auctions. Her alleged malfeasance borders on performance art.

For the uninitiated, let’s consult the ledger (assuming anyone can find it):

  1. $20 million in misplaced proceeds

  2. Skyrocketing courthouse security incidents

  3. Glaring staffing turnover, glacial deed delays, unaccounted firearms, slush funds, no-bid contracts, sexual harassment, retaliation against whistleblowers

  4. Nearly $10,000 spent on a costumed mascot

Not bad for a proclaimed reformer swept into office in 2019 on vows to spruce up a department synonymous with scandal. The reported dysfunction has grown so spectacular that Bilal’s defenders appear to have settled on a curious standard of innocence: Unless that misplaced $20 million turns up in her mattress, what’s the problem?

It all seemingly earned Bilal, 69, the respect of her colleagues. Or at least the endorsement of the Democratic City Committee, which had Bilal’s back for a second term in 2023 even as the mismanagement mounted. Earlier this month, City Council, which honored Bilal just months ago, announced it has finally decided to look under the hood, if not the mattress.

My colleagues Willian Bender and Ryan Briggs have been doggedly following this positively byzantine case for years. The judge’s pending contempt decision represents the next big domino. The Inquirer will be there when the decision comes down.

Bender told me, “In terms of [Council President Kenyatta] Johnson stepping in and saying, ‘We want to hold hearings to look at this significant office’ — I think that’s pretty significant, assuming they follow through with the hearings and are interested in getting to the bottom of it.”

Hearings are easy. Answers are harder.

Johnson, who authorized the hearings scheduled for next month, was careful to note that he remains “good friends” with Bilal. Nothing personal, Sheriff. It’s just the public’s money.

Data deep dive: A.C. street-legal edition

Atlantic City bet big on legal weed. The payoff? Shuttered storefronts, struggling businesses, and a federal bribery investigation, as my colleague Amy Rosenberg reports. A distinctly Atlantic City kind of bad trip.

Video of the Week

Holiday-week homework: Read my colleague Ariel Simpson’s fist-pumping profile of South Philly boxer Hank Lundy, who’s transforming himself into an old-school practitioner of the sweet science. Root for Lundy as he makes his bare-knuckle boxing debut on Saturday at Estrella Studios in Burbank, Calif.

A look ahead: Turkey Week edition

  1. Mother Nature hates Philly, too. Chilly rain and gusty winds are forecast Thursday for the 107th edition of the nation’s oldest Thanksgiving Day parade. Whatever. Pack your turkey-proof poncho and cheer your lungs out for the “Firsties Float,” a 250th-themed rolling spectacle celebrating the city’s endless historic contributions.

  2. Yo, it’s Christmas, hon! Christmas Village in Philadelphia returns Thursday. Running through Dec. 27, this year’s market includes changes to make shopping easier for visitors with disabilities.

  3. The Revolution are coming. Again. And this time the Union need to be ready. After losing Game 1, the Union host the New England Revolution in Game 2 of their first-round MLS playoff series.

One more thing: The American Revolution faced doom in December 1776

Bucks County. December 1776.

The American Revolution is on the brink of collapse. And George Washington knows it. He trembles for Philadelphia.

Washington, 44, writes by wavering candlelight in the borrowed rooms of a stately stone mansion. He wishes to Heaven his quill could convey a more favorable tale. The general is on the run. The British have blasted him from his fortifications in New York and chased him clear across New Jersey, and over the Delaware River into Pennsylvania. His soldiers are sick and starving and disappearing. The Revolution is coming apart. George Washington is fighting to keep his army alive.

In Philadelphia, not 30 miles away, the citizenry has calculated the grim arithmetic. An estimated 15,000 Philadelphians —roughly half the city — flee for Bucks and Chester Counties, or to Delaware and Maryland. Even the Congress, conspiring at the State House at Sixth and Chestnut, reconvenes in Baltimore. The birthplace of American independence can be mistaken for a ghost town.

“If this fails,” Washington writes of his hopes for fresh troops to a cousin at Mount Vernon, letting the mask of command slip, “I think the game will be pretty well up.”

This week, I’ll be writing more about these dark days of rebellion, just before a remarkable turn of fortune: the Ten Crucial Days, when Washington and his ragtag army snatched improbable victories at Trenton and Princeton, reviving a dying cause.

In the meantime, use a bit of your holiday week to check out that very December 1776 Washington letter, now on display at the Museum on the American Revolution. A rare glimpse of Washington at his lowest, the relic marks 250 years since that winter of 1776, when a newly minted nation teetered on extinction. Desperation pours through Washington’s elegant, looping script. A reminder of how close it all came to ending before it had barely begun. It gave me chills.

Like a lot of you, I’m taking next weekend to relax with my family. I’ll be back on the first Sunday in December. Happy Thanksgiving! Go Birds!

Inquirer logo

Sunday Evening note

Future product

Would you like to get Mike Newall's dispatch on Sunday evenings? Be first on the list to get the newsletter when it launches.