Skip to content

Smallwood: How Earnie Stewart is continuing to improve the Union

The Philadelphia Union recent signings of English striker Jay Simpson and Dutch left back Giliano Wijnaldum are the type of moves you hope are indicative of Sporting Director Earnie Stewart’s understanding of the back alleys of European football and how to find a few genuine jewels amidst a market full of baubles and trinkets.
I’m not going to pretend that I know a thing about Simpson, who was signed from Leyton Orient of League Two – the fourth tier of English soccer, or Wijnaldum, who comes from VfL Bochum of 2. Bundesliga – the second tier in Germany.
Still, in theory, these were the type of signings I’d hoped Stewart would make when he was placed in charge of the Union last January.
It’s no secret that the Union ownership does not have the deep pockets like the Los Angeles Galaxy, New York City FC or Toronto FC.
The ZOLOs can’t snap up a big-ticket international like Giovani dos Santos, David Villa or Sebastian Giovinco.
Creative roster building was going to be Stewart’s thing. He was going to have to hit on players who might be off the radar but might thrive in Major League Soccer.
In Stewart’s first year, he made moves in the SuperDraft to select defender Keegan Rosenberry, who was an MLS All-Star and recent call up for the United States Men’s Senior Team, plus defender Joshua Yaro and midfielder Fabian Herbers in the top six.
He signed midfielder Ilsinho, attacking midfielder Roland Alberg,  defender Ken Tribbett and midfielder Warren Creavalle.
Stewart used the FIFA summer transfer window to get USMNT defender Alejandro Bedoya from Nance of Ligue 1 in France.
Every player Stewart acquired played a strong role in the Union making the MLS Playoffs for the first time in four seasons and second time overall.
Stewart has a strong starting record.
As a once promising member in the youth ranks of the national team of the Netherlands, Wijnaldum, 24, is exactly the type of young player the Union should take a flier on.
He’s played five of his professional seasons in Eredivisie – the top flight of Dutch football.
Simpson, 28, is the guy I find most intriguing.
In their six-year history, the Union has never been able to acquire or develop a goal-scoring forward who could put fear in the opposition.
Midfielder/forward Chris Pontius (12) and Alberg (9) were the Union’s leading scorers in 2016 but neither is a pure striker.
I’m going way out on a limb with hope, but Simpson’s career thus far seems similar to that of New York Red Bulls scoring sensation Bradley Wright-Phillips before he came to MLS from England at 28 years old.
Wright-Phillips, like Simpson, got some brief early time in the Premier League but spent most of his career in the lower tiers of English football, scoring 78 goals in 240 appearances.
In 107 MLS games, Wright-Phillips has 69 goals and won two Golden Boots (top goal scorer) in the last three seasons. He is the first MLS player with two 20-plus goal seasons.
Obviously, that is a high bar for Simpson, who scored 41 goals in 230 appearances in English leagues. Wright-Phillips’ case is still one of a diamond in the rough.
There is a lot to handling the adjustments to MLS and there is no guarantee that Simpson is the quality of player Wright-Phillips is.
Still, thus far, Stewart’s instincts have been correct on virtually every player that he’s brought in. That’s a good sign as he continues to improve the culture of the Union.
 ​
Join The Conversation