Skip to content

Expect a flood of class-action suits, says Ballard's Alan Kaplinsky

New consumer-protection rules expected to take effect next year will unleash a flood of suits against banks, credit card firms and others, says a lawyer who has been battling for financial service clients for much of his career.

Alan Kaplinsky of Ballard Spahr predicts "a huge increase in class actions,"
Alan Kaplinsky of Ballard Spahr predicts "a huge increase in class actions,"Read more

New consumer-protection rules expected to take effect next year will unleash a flood of suits against banks, credit card firms and others, says a lawyer who has been battling for financial service clients for much of his career.

Alan Kaplinsky, head of Ballard Spahr's financial services group, said a proposal by the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to drop a prohibition on class-action lawsuits in many credit card and banking contracts would spur plaintiffs lawyers to sue.

"We are going to see a huge increase in class actions," he said.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau unveiled the proposal May 5 and industry insiders expect it to become law next year.

The rule would ban credit card firms and others from requiring customers to submit disputes to arbitration while also waiving the right to file class actions.

The use of such arbitration agreements was pioneered by Kaplinsky more than a decade ago, and it effectively eliminated class actions as a vehicle for consumers to seek redress from some financial services companies.

His clients had long complained of class actions that plaintiffs lawyers used to extract settlements in cases with little merit.

"Many of the class actions get filed by lawyers who are not real class-action lawyers," Kaplinsky said. "They are people who use class actions as leverage to extract a settlement."

But the consumer bureau, which conducted a lengthy study of class-action waivers, found that credit card agreements and other financial service contracts barring class actions deprived consumers of a key protection.

The bureau found that although millions of consumers are covered by class-action waivers and arbitration requirements, only a few hundred sought to arbitrate complaints during the period studied, from 2010 to 2012.

"The use of class-action waivers "has evolved to the point where it effectively functions as a kind of legal lockout," said bureau director Richard Cordray. "Companies simply insert these clauses into their contracts for consumer financial products or services and literally with the stroke of a pen are able to block any group of consumers form filing. . .class actions."

Class-actions lawsuits are a legal tactic used by consumers, businesses, and others with similar claims to demand compensation as a group. The bureau said the tactic was once important and could be again, especially for bank and credit card customers and others with claims against financial services companies.

That is because the claims, for interest rate overcharges and improper late fees, for example, typically are too small to justify the cost of litigating them individually.

But pooled together, such claims can collectively reach tens of millions of dollars in value, serving as an incentive for plaintiffs firms to take the case.

The bureau's proposal would permit companies to continue to offer arbitration. But they would no longer be able to bar customers from filing class actions.

The proposed rule, which is expected to become final in the second half of 2017, would apply only to agreements done after its enactment.

"A lot of companies will abandon arbitration and take it out of their agreements going forward if they are not longer able to obtain the benefit of avoiding class actions," Kaplinsky said.

cmondics@phillynews.com

215-854-5957 @cmondics