Skip to content

Cheap-labor era in China is disappearing

SHANGHAI, China - Factory workers demanding better wages and working conditions are hastening the end of an era of cheap costs that helped make southern coastal China the world's factory floor.

SHANGHAI, China - Factory workers demanding better wages and working conditions are hastening the end of an era of cheap costs that helped make southern coastal China the world's factory floor.

Strikes over the last two months have been a rude wake-up call for the many foreign companies that depend on China's low costs to compete overseas, from makers of Christmas trees to makers of gadgets such as the iPad.

Where once low-tech factories and scant wages were welcomed in a China eager to escape isolation and poverty, workers now demand a bigger share of the profit. The government, meanwhile, is pushing foreign companies to invest in high tech and other areas it believes will create greater wealth for China.

Many companies are striving to stay profitable by shifting factories to cheaper locations farther inland or to other developing countries. A few are even resuming production in the West.

"China is going to go through a very dramatic period. The big companies are starting to exit," said Rick Goodwin, a China trade veteran of 22 years, whose company links foreign buyers with Chinese suppliers.

Goodwin says dissatisfied workers and hard-to-predict exchange rates are his top worries.

Beijing's decision to stop tethering the Chinese currency to the U.S. dollar, allowing it to appreciate and thus boosting costs in yuan, has multiplied the uncertainty for companies already struggling with meager profit margins.

Wham-O Inc., which created the Hula Hoop and Slip 'N Slide, decided to bring half of its Frisbee production and some production of other items back to the United States.

At the other end of the scale, some in research-intensive sectors such as pharmaceutical, biotech, and other life-sciences companies are also reconsidering China for reasons including costs and incentives offered in other countries.

"Life-sciences companies have shifted some production back to the U.S. from China. In some cases, the U.S. was becoming cheaper," said Sean Correll, director of consulting services for Emptoris, based in Burlington, Mass.

Even with recent increases, wages for Chinese workers are still a fraction of those for Americans. But studies do show China's overall cost advantage is shrinking.

Labor costs have been climbing about 15 percent a year since a 2008 labor-contract law that made workers more aware of their rights. Tax preferences for foreign companies ended in 2007. Land, water, energy, and shipping costs are rising.

In its most recent survey, issued in February, restructuring firm Alix Partners found that, overall, China was more expensive than Mexico, India, Vietnam, Russia, and Romania.

Mexico, in particular, has gained an edge, thanks to the North American Free Trade Agreement and to fast, inexpensive trucking, says Mike Romeri, an executive with Emptoris, the consulting firm.

Makers of toys and trinkets, Christmas trees, and cheap shoes already have folded by the thousands or moved away, some to Vietnam, Indonesia, or Cambodia. But those countries lack the huge workforce, infrastructure, and markets China can offer, and most face the same labor issues as China.

So far, the biggest impact appears to be around Shenzhen, a former fishing village in Guangdong province, bordering Hong Kong, that is home to thousands of export manufacturers.

That includes Taiwan-based Foxconn Technology, a supplier of iPhones and iPads to Apple Inc. Foxconn responded to suicides at its Shenzhen complex with pay increases that more than doubled basic monthly worker salaries to $290. Strike-stricken suppliers to Honda Motor Co. and Toyota Motor Corp., among many others, also have raised wages.

Foxconn refused repeated requests for comment on plans to move much of its manufacturing capacity to central China's impoverished Henan province, where a local government website has advertised for tens of thousands of workers on its behalf.

But among other projects farther inland, Foxconn is teaming up with some of the biggest global computer-makers to build what may be the world's largest laptop-production hub in Chongqing, a western China city of 32 million, where labor costs are estimated to be 20 percent to 40 percent lower than in coastal cities.