City Council questions limits on charter school growth
At a time when the state legislature is mulling placing more restrictions on charter schools, City Council held an unusual hearing last night to question whether the Philadelphia School District has too much oversight over charters.

At a time when the state legislature is mulling placing more restrictions on charter schools, City Council held an unusual hearing last night to question whether the Philadelphia School District has too much oversight over charters.
"Charter school operators tell me that they must meet standards that the public schools don't," said Councilwoman Jannie L. Blackwell, chairwoman of Council's Education Committee.
Other Council members expressed concerns that the district's efforts to limit charter growth were limiting educational options for Philadelphians.
The session focused on a proposed change in the way the district regulates when charters can increase their enrollment or change their grade configurations.
District Superintendent Arlene Ackerman said she was working on a proposal that would allow charters to make changes after three years, or when their operating charters come up for renewal, usually every five years.
She also said the district had decided to consider all pending requests for grade changes and enrollment increases for schools close to meeting academic standards under the federal No Child Left Behind Act.
The proposals, she said, are a compromise to a draft proposed two months ago that provided less flexibility.
State Sen. Anthony Williams (D., Phila.), who founded the Hardy Williams Charter School in West Philadelphia and helped develop the compromise, said the changes would allow charter schools to expand.
Several charter operators said the proposals aired last night were a marked improvement, but at least one charter operator had reservations.
Martin Ryder, chief executive of World Communications Charter School, said the proposed policy was illegal because it violated the state law that prohibits capping charter enrollment.
Ackerman said that the district's lawyers concluded the proposed policy was legal.
The School Reform Commission is expected to vote on the proposed policy later this fall.
Apart from testifying about the district's $3.2 billion budget in May, it was Ackerman's first appearance before Council, and she faced tough questioning.
Councilman Bill Green got into a testy exchange with Ackerman as he pressed her to explain a comment she had made about the historically rocky relations between the district and the charters.
Ackerman said she had heard about some instances that happened before her arrival to Philadelphia, but could not remember what she was told or by whom.
"You can't remember?" Green asked sarcastically. "That's credible."
Ackerman said she realized City Council has a stake in the district's success, but added: "I would like to be talked to in a civil way because I'm trying to answer the question . . . I would like respect."
"I still want the respect of real answers to real questions," he responded.
























