Skip to content

Editorial | Guantanamo

One guilty plea doesn't cure all

Shackles are chained to the floor inside an interrogation room at the maximum security detention facility at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
Shackles are chained to the floor inside an interrogation room at the maximum security detention facility at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.Read more

Yes, the military tribunal at Guantanamo Bay finally got a guilty plea on a terrorism charge this week, from a 31-year-old Australian.

Don't let anyone try to convince you that that result somehow justifies the affront to American values that is the Gitmo detention camp, with its dubious tribunals now getting geared up.

David Hicks pleaded guilty late Monday to being an al-Qaeda wannabe, having reportedly attended a training camp and met Osama bin Laden. Big fish, he was not.

What's more, his plea seemed to be driven by a desire to do anything possible to get out of Guantanamo, which his father described as an "absolute hell." Hicks will be jailed for a time, but back in his own country.

Quite a triumph for the home of the free and the land of the brave.

The legal process leading to the surprise guilty plea was passing strange. Far from demonstrating that the military trials would be conducted fairly, this bizarre proceeding included a judge booting Hicks' two civilian lawyers off the case.

Some of the detainees at Gitmo are clearly malevolent enemies of America, such as terror-kingpin suspect Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, who has claimed credit for everything but being John Wilkes Booth's handler.

But the administration has never been keen on careful procedures that might discriminate between the truly dangerous and those whose detentions were only the product of the chaos of war.

The open-ended Guantanamo detentions remain deeply troubling, all the more so due to the Bush administration's refusal to grant foreign prisoners the right to make habeas corpus appeals to the federal courts. Don't just take the word of rights groups for that: Check with Robert M. Gates, the American defense secretary.

On the eve of the Hicks trial, administration officials confirmed that Gates argued for closing Guantanamo because the terror-suspect legal proceedings had given the United States such a black eye overseas.

Gates hasn't won the day yet within the Bush administration, but give him credit for trying. He also succeeded in derailing a misguided plan to build a $100 million courthouse and detention center at Guantanamo. That would have given the clear impression that the detention camp was a permanent fixture, when even Bush claimed otherwise.

Detainee defense attorneys, including those working pro bono out of Philadelphia law firms, view the restoration of habeas corpus rights - an 800-year-old tradition in Anglo-American law - as key.

Congress should pass a measure to restore that fundamental human-rights protection; among the sponsors is Sen. Arlen Specter (R., Pa.). That is not only the right thing to do, but it might bolster Gates' bid to close the detention center as well.

You see, the Bush administration has a habit of backing down on points that it formerly claimed were vital to national security, whenever federal courts are about to rule against it. If habeas appeals were restored, authorities just might decide to empty Guantanamo.

If Congress restored habeas rights, Bush might veto. Then it might be up to the U.S. Supreme Court to uphold this fundamental principle of American justice.

Congress or the courts: Whoever does it, someone who cares about America's future has to uphold the values of due process and impartial justice that distinguish this nation from its enemies.