Act now on city schools
By Christine Carlson Putting Philadelphia public schools on par with their suburban counterparts is a huge task, but dramatic improvements can be made almost immediately if City Council acts and the School Reform Commission and the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers compromise.
By Christine Carlson
Putting Philadelphia public schools on par with their suburban counterparts is a huge task, but dramatic improvements can be made almost immediately if City Council acts and the School Reform Commission and the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers compromise.
In the city and suburbs, schools are posting teaching positions for next year, and teachers are considering their options now. But, even if they wanted to, these teachers can't consider potential jobs in the School District of Philadelphia because most positions are not posted or filled until August or September. As a result, Philadelphia schools are at a significant competitive disadvantage when retaining and attracting the region's best and brightest teachers. We can change this scenario.
First, City Council must release the $120 million already authorized by the commonwealth to extend the city's additional 1 percent sales tax so that Superintendent William R. Hite Jr. can effectively plan for and post open teaching positions now. The release is being held up by Council President Darrell Clarke, who wants to allocate half of this money toward solving the city's long-term pension problem.
Though I believe that extending the sales tax hurts Philadelphia in the long run, if it is going to happen, the entire amount should go to our most pressing immediate need: our schools. The pension issue is significant, but not as imminent as the need to fund our schools. Ensuring that today's students graduate with the ability to contribute to (rather than drain) our city's resources will put us in a better position to close the pension deficit in the future.
Splitting these funds would also require state legislators to amend the current law. On the slim chance they did, it would not be until next year. That's too little, and far too late.
Second, the PFT and the School District must compromise on a contract. Why would any good teacher want to remain or start teaching in the district when an imposed contract looms on the horizon? With Bill Green as SRC chairman, the likelihood of this has gone from possible to probable, and both sides need to settle quickly.
The SRC must get past the ludicrous notion that teachers should accept a 13 percent pay cut. Retaining and attracting the best teachers requires that salaries be competitive with other parts of our region. The PFT has already agreed to a pay freeze and contributions toward health insurance and should not have to concede additional compensation.
However, the PFT needs to allow for universal site selection. Rather than having teachers placed in a school based solely on seniority, the site-selection process would allow a committee - the principal, teachers, and parents - to interview and select teachers they believe are not only proficient, but also philosophically embrace the vision of the school.
Some teachers are threatened by this, particularly because the current process allows a principal to veto a committee's selection. It would seem reasonable, then, to have this veto power removed in any new contract. However, it's clear that Hite does not intend to budge on the larger issue, as it is essential to the principal autonomy model he wants to implement.
What is best for our children is more important than an individual teacher's desire to be placed at a particular school.
In order for schools to start hiring teachers for the next school year, universal site selection must be implemented now. Waiting to fill positions in August or early September is too late.
Parents don't wait until the last minute to make decisions about where their children will go to school, and teaching positions should not be last-minute assignments. Our public officials and the PFT must recognize that. They must create a process that helps Philadelphia district schools retain and hire the very best teachers. We have a small window of opportunity to make a real difference for next year. City Council, the SRC, and the PFT should act now.
























