Skip to content

Jefferson Health will leave Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey’s network on March 1 without a new contract

In addition to Horizon, New Jersey's largest insurer, Jefferson is in high-stakes contract talks with at least two other major insurers, Highmark and Independence Blue Cross.

Jefferson Cherry Hill Hospital is among three that will be out of network next year with Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey next year if Jefferson and New Jersey's biggest health insurer can't reach a new agreement.
Jefferson Cherry Hill Hospital is among three that will be out of network next year with Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey next year if Jefferson and New Jersey's biggest health insurer can't reach a new agreement.Read moreTom Gralish / Staff Photographer

Jefferson Health and Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey have reached in impasse in contract talks, leading both to warn patients that Jefferson’s three South Jersey hospitals will leave Horizon’s network on March 1 if they fail to reach a new agreement.

Insurers and health systems typically reach agreements before contracts expire, but Jefferson has been taking a particularly tough approach with insurers during a period of significant operating losses for the Philadelphia region’s largest health system. Jefferson’s Lehigh Valley Health Network went out of network with UnitedHealthcare in two phases last year and this year.

A Horizon website for commercial patients said that meeting Jefferson’s demands would cost Horizon members more than $185 million over the next three years and that New Jersey residents should not have to pay for Jefferson’s losses in Pennsylvania. Horizon, based in Newark, N.J., did not say how much of a percentage increase Jefferson is seeking.

A separate notice said that Jefferson had terminated its Medicaid contract with Horizon effective Sunday, but added that under New Jersey law patients will be able to continue receiving in-network care at Jefferson’s Cherry Hill, Stratford, and Washington Township hospitals through Feb. 28.

“It is particularly disappointing that Jefferson canceled the agreement we had reached for members who rely on Medicaid for their health coverage and is now using them as leverage. That is beyond unfair and unreasonable,” Horizon said in an email. “Horizon has offered an increase that reflects inflation, and we’re ready to negotiate an agreement that helps make care more affordable for the people we serve.”

Jefferson’s online communication to patients said that Horizon pays other South Jersey hospitals 146% more on average than Jefferson for inpatient care and up to 89% more for emergency care.

Jefferson said it wants Horizon to narrow the gap, not make it the highest-paid system.

“Jefferson was in active negotiations with Horizon when they decided to abruptly cancel all discussions,” Jefferson said in a statement. “They’re putting patients’ well being at risk by refusing to continue conversations with us. We stand ready to meet with Horizon any time, any day, any location on behalf of our patients.”

Neither Jefferson nor Horizon said how many patients would be affected if they can’t agree to a new contract. In New Jersey, cancer and psychiatric patients would be able to continue receiving in-network care from Jefferson for a year even without a new contract, Horizon said.

In its dispute with Independence Blue Cross in Southeastern Pennsylvania, Jefferson is not focused on local competitors but rather on what it says is Independence’s underpayment relative to national averages for the entire market.

Jefferson also issued a notice that it could go out of network with Highmark, Pennsylvania’s largest Blue Cross Blue Shield company, on Jan. 1.

Editor’s note: This article has been updated to note that Horizon posted separate notices for commercial and Medicaid patients and to clarify that Jefferson is comparing Horizon’s rates to other hospitals in South Jersey. Another update added a statement from Horizon.