Bill on Phila. billboards advances
A new effort to regulate Philadelphia's outdoor advertising that would legalize all existing billboards and permit conversion of some to brighter digital displays won clearance Tuesday from a City Council committee and is poised for final passage within several weeks.
A new effort to regulate Philadelphia's outdoor advertising that would legalize all existing billboards and permit conversion of some to brighter digital displays won clearance Tuesday from a City Council committee and is poised for final passage within several weeks.
The bill's prime sponsor, Councilman Bobby Henon, praised it as a difficult compromise between the billboard industry and community groups and one likely to leave both factions somewhat unhappy.
Representatives of the city's biggest outdoor advertisers complained about a proposed boost in license fees from $50 to $315 a year for most billboards. Henon says he intends to amend the bill to reduce the figure by an as-yet-unspecified amount.
The strongest criticism of the bill came from community groups and Scenic Philadelphia, the antibillboard organization formerly known as SCRUB. They called the legislation a near-surrender to the industry, which has managed to defang past efforts at city regulation with aggressive court challenges.
Parts of the bill would "protect illegal billboards knowingly constructed against Philadelphia's sign code," testified Amy Hillier, an associate professor of city and regional planning at the University of Pennsylvania's School of Design.
She distributed photos showing five Clear Channel billboards directly opposite schools, libraries, and a recreation center, locations barred under the city code.
Stephanie Kosta, an attorney for the outdoor advertising industry, said the characterization of many billboards as "illegal" was mistaken.
"All of the billboards were lawfully constructed at the time they were constructed," Kosta said. She said some dated to the 1920s and had been grandfathered into legality when the city imposed outdoor advertising restrictions. "This whole conception of a bunch of illegal billboards out there is untrue," she said.
Council's Rules Committee approved the bill unanimously and sent it to the Council floor, where members predicted final passage.
A spokesman for the Nutter administration, Mark McDonald, was noncommittal, saying the mayor's staff needed to review Henon's amendments and confer with Council "to get a more clear idea of this piece of legislation and its rationale."
Scenic Philadelphia contends enforcement of billboard restrictions has been virtually nonexistent since 2006, when Mayor John F. Street's administration reached an out-of-court settlement with the city's major outdoor advertising companies.
That agreement is set to expire next year, leaving the rules unsettled at a time when many companies are looking to convert traditional billboards to digital displays.
Under the proposal, billboard companies would be allowed to convert signs to digital without a zoning change if the signs are within "digital conversion zones" to be designated by Council. Each conversion will require a sign owner to remove another sign in the same zone.
Henon said he expected district Council members to control conversion zone boundaries inside their districts, reconciling the positions of advertisers and community groups.
Because of other restrictions in the bill that would keep digital-display billboards away from residential, historic, park and school areas, Henon predicted the digital signs would be limited to areas near major highways.
























