Skip to content

Wills Eye loses Medicare appeal for hospital designation

A second federal appeals panel has ruled against Wills Eye Hospital's bid to be designated as a hospital under Medicare.

"We disagree with that decision and are exploring all of our legal options," Wills said in a statement Friday.

Wills was facing a Tuesday cutoff on all Medicare reimbursement because its treatment of inpatients violates its Medicare certification as an ambulatory surgery center, but separately on Friday it got a reprieve from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS).

"Wills Eye Hospital will continue business as usual, except that we will not be able to treat patients who require more than 24 hours of care after Nov. 26," Wills said.

"For all of our patients who do not require more than 24 hours of hospital care, the decision will have no impact on their treatment," Wills said. It will work with nearby Thomas Jefferson University Hospital to handle patients who need more than 24 hours of care.

In its 40-page decision, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services' Departmental Appeals Board found that "CMS reasonably exercised its discretion in determining that the facts and circumstances surrounding Wills' operations did not demonstrate that it qualified as a hospital for Medicare purposes."

Federal regulations say a hospital primarily engages in providing services to inpatients. Wills has four inpatient beds.

Wills argued that CMS used a numerical standard for the ratio of inpatients to outpatients as a basis for its rejection in 2013 of Wills' application for Medicare certification as hospital. The board said in its decision that the 17.4 percent ratio of inpatients to outpatients cited by Wills came from the Pennsylvania Department of Health, which presented the figure in support of Wills' application.

Dale Van Wieren, the official in CMS's Philadelphia branch who denied Wills' application, examined how the facility would change if it received certification as a hospital and concluded that "the primary work of the facility was still the outpatient ASC [ambulatory surgery center] practice, and that it did not meet the definition of a hospital primarily engaged in providing inpatient services," according to a legal document quoted in the board decision.

The next legal stop for Wills could be federal court, either in Philadelphia or Washington.

CMS officials in Philadelphia had no comment.

"This is the wrong decision by CMS but this fight is not over,"  U.S. Sen. Bob Casey said in a statement. "I am going to continue to appeal to the administration to step in and review this process."

The appeals board decision made it clear "that Wills' attempt to transform itself back into a hospital by the addition of a small inpatient component is, at least in significant part, driven by the desire for higher payment rates" received by hospitals, but it also suggested that the Wills case raises questions about whether the categories of Medicare providers and payment rates are outdated.

"We have recognized that Wills makes a compelling presentation that it offers valuable, even unique, services that are not well accounted for by the structures built into the Medicare financing system," the board said.

"Unfortunately, we are aware of no category of Medicare providers reimbursed at higher rates for high-acuity outpatient care while also providing a small amount of inpatient care," it said.