
Jeffrey Tubbs has found a way to survive and thrive in a difficult residential real estate market:
Start small, build green, price it right, work with your neighbors, and, even better, buy a unit and live there.
The result: the Flats at Girard Pointe at Third Street and Germantown Avenue in Kensington, just above Northern Liberties. The eco-friendly project of five townhouses and four condos, begun in early 2008 on an 8,000-square-foot lot bought from the city Redevelopment Authority, commands prices of $300,000 to $450,000.
"That was a tough one - pricing," Tubbs said. "We took [comparables] from south of Girard Avenue and a few further east. There's enough construction going on that we knew we couldn't be $500,000-and-up like Northern Liberties, so we shot for a benchmark, changed some numbers, and adjusted finishes."
Four modular townhouses have been completed and sold. The second phase, a townhouse and four condos, has received not only the requisite approvals, but financing from Downingtown National Bank First N.A.
Three of the Phase 2 units have been presold, which, along with the success of the first phase, helped secure the financing in these tight times.
The fact that Tubbs, 33, city planner, contractor's son, and president of JDT International, bought one of the townhouses for himself has been a big plus for his neighbors and his buyers.
"A lot of developers come and say, 'We have the money, and we can build what we want,' " said Ann Moss, president of the Old Kensington Neighborhood Association. "Jeff living here and his involvement in the neighborhood has made a big difference. The neighbors here have no problem with development as long as it is responsible development.
"If you respect the neighborhood and its wishes, we are friendly and welcoming."
That Tubbs plays basketball with the youths at Cruz Recreation Center also has impressed Moss.
"I love basketball, and I'm not out of shape yet," he said.
Tubbs and Moss are working to develop programs for the neighborhood's young people - "our future leaders," Moss calls them. A mentoring program (with the assistance of the Ace Mentor Program of Eastern Pennsylvania) is using the second phase of the project as a case study.
"Everyone appears to be excited and on board," Tubbs said, quickly acknowledging that this kind of involvement needs to be balanced by the requirements of the project's investors and lenders.
That said, he is also presenting grant proposals to the Pepsi Refresh Project and SugarHouse casino to develop the mentoring program, as well as to update the sports facilities at Cruz.
To meet the Redevelopment Authority's art requirement for new projects, Tubbs contracted with InLiquid, a Philadelphia visual-arts nonprofit group, to determine a design.
Buyers at the Flats at Girard Pointe seem to be just fine with all this.
John and Pam Trovato, who are in their early 30s, moved there from Old City - they live in the townhouse next door to Tubbs.
The fruits of the developer's commitment to the neighborhood are obvious to them, John Trovato said, "because our neighbors on Germantown Avenue came over to introduce themselves when we moved in." And "to know that he's right next door gives us a level of comfort" he said of Tubbs.
Trovato said he saw Old Kensington as a place that offered opportunities to be active but that was quieter - important "as we get older."
"When we need things to be tweaked, [Tubbs] sends someone over," Trovato said. "When we were buying, he was willing to do whatever we wanted done.
"We looked all over, and it was the value that sold us."
Though Tubbs' methods might not be conventional, where and what he is building is typical of what's keeping the city's residential-construction market viable during this economic downturn.
"Right now, the majority of private projects are small, usually ranging in size from one to five units," said Sam Sherman, president of the Building Industry Association of Philadelphia.
"This is the only segment of the market that is moving," Sherman said, "but very few of these projects are built on spec, as far as I can tell. The smaller guys usually line up a buyer before the home is finished."
They have a cost advantage over larger-production builders - lower overhead and reduced construction costs (Tubbs uses union labor) - "and are pricing their homes to avoid the jumbo-mortgage category [over $417,000]," Sherman said.
Lee Herzer, assistant vice president of commercial lending at Downingtown National Bank, has worked with Tubbs and his investor/partners, CLR2 Associates of Philadelphia, since 2008, when Herzer was with TD Bank N.A., the lender for the first, completed phase.
"It appeared to us [Downingtown National] that the project was well-priced for the market, offers a lot of 'green' that buyers are looking for as amenities and value," Herzer said. "There is really strong demand for it in this market."
Tubbs quickly pointed out that although his project is green enough for Energy Star certification, "we didn't want to take too many risks." So there are no green roofs or koi ponds, such as at the Ice House project nearby in Fishtown, another big seller.
The fact that the first phase of the Flats at Girard Pointe sold out and the second had presales also attracted the financing, Herzer said.
Given the economic climate, he said, his bank - and small and midsize lenders in general - is not looking to finance large-scale subdivisions. But Herzer is high on Philadelphia and investing in neighborhoods such as Northern Liberties and Brewerytown.
"If you look at all the cities in the country, Philadelphia is one that is in the best shape and well-positioned for the recovery," he said.
Projects such as Tubbs' are a key part of that recovery.
"These projects tend to draw the 'big fish' into areas of the city because they tend to stabilize the neighborhoods and provide the [comparables] necessary to obtain funding for larger projects," Sherman said.
"These smaller builder/developers form the backbone of the industry right now," he said. "Their success is a harbinger of better times ahead - the canary in the coal mine."
























