Phila. schools outline reforms after warning on grants
The Philadelphia School District has proposed a series of management changes in response to a scathing federal audit that found inadequate documentation for nearly $140 million in expenditures and resulted in a recommendation that city schools be placed on a fiscal watch list.

The Philadelphia School District has proposed a series of management changes in response to a scathing federal audit that found inadequate documentation for nearly $140 million in expenditures and resulted in a recommendation that city schools be placed on a fiscal watch list.
While auditors initially called for the return of $17 million in federal funds, district officials on Friday formally outlined the district's reforms and stressed that the U.S. Department of Education has never demanded repayment of any federal subsidies.
Nonetheless, state and federal education officials are due in Philadelphia at the end of the month for a progress report.
In April, based on the January audit findings, an official in the Department of Education's Inspector General's Office recommended designating the district a "high-risk grantee," meaning it would have been on a watch list for how it spent federal dollars.
While the audit covered the 2005-06 school year, when the district was under the leadership of Paul Vallas, some of the management practices called into question are only now being addressed.
If it had been tagged with the "high-risk" label, the district would have had to spend money out of its own pocket, then apply for reimbursement. Such a move would cost the district millions in borrowing expenses.
State and federal education officials had not, as of Friday, moved to designate the district as high-risk.
The Pennsylvania Department of Education is satisfied with the district's progress, a department spokeswoman said Friday.
"We are working with the School District, alongside the U.S. Department of Education, to identify those issues in the audit," said spokeswoman Leah Harris. "As the School District is moving forward with an action plan to address the organizational management issues identified, we are happy with that action plan."
The 130-page audit criticized the district for faulty bookkeeping and poor records management. It said the district had not enforced required staff certifications, improperly used some grant money to pay for ineligible salaries, failed to show what work some employees performed, and inadequately explained how some of the money had been used to pay for food, training materials, computers, and class trips.
The district rebutted the audit in a 45-page response, calling many allegations the result of a "fundamental misunderstanding" of how it managed the grants. Refunding the money would have a "devastating impact" on the district's mission, it said.
Michael Masch, the district's chief financial officer, said he and members of his staff met with state and federal education officials in May to outline fixes the district was making.
Those include writing more timely reports on the activities of teachers and staff whose salaries are paid for with grant money, and designating employees whose sole job is to make sure those teachers and staff are coded properly in district records.
The district will also hire an outside contractor to write a grants policies and procedures manual - something most school systems have but Philadelphia does not, Masch said - and will then train employees based on the manual.
"The U.S. Department of Education has a high degree of comfort that our corrective action plan is taking the district in the right direction for grants compliance," Masch said.
Masch said the district acknowledged the deficiencies in grant controls that happened in the Vallas era.
"The U.S. Department of Education has made no proposal that we refund dollars based on the inspector general's assertion that some of our spending was unallowable," Masch said. "They have not made any indication that they seek to do that."
























