Skip to content

Pollution case set for another review

A federal judge is to reconsider whether New Jersey can fine a railroad over its use of trash transfer sites.

NEWARK, N.J. - A federal appeals court has revived an effort by New Jersey environmental regulators to fine a railroad over its operation of four trash transfer stations the state claims were not properly overseen.

At the stations, trash is loaded from trucks onto trains, then sent by rail to dumps in other states. New Jersey maintains that sloppy trash transfer procedures can lead to air and water pollution.

In order to ensure clean transfers are done, the state contends it has authority to fine railroads that do not comply with state guidelines.

The 3-0 decision sends the case back to a federal judge in Newark, who had ruled that the garbage stations are subject to a federal law but not to more stringent New Jersey environmental rules.

Officials in New Jersey welcomed the ruling.

"It is important that consistent rules for managing solid waste remain intact and that residents are not harmed by an uneven observance of protections of health, safety and our environment," said Christopher Gale, a spokesman for the New Jersey Meadowlands Commission.

Steve Thomas, a Hainesport, Burlington County, resident whose property backs up on a solid-waste trash transfer station called the Hainesport Industrial Railroad, said yesterday the federal appeals court's decision is a "positive step. It should help."

Thomas has been fighting a losing battle against his neighbor, often complaining about the refuse blowing into his yard and about stacked rail containers towering 45 feet over his property.

Sen. Frank R. Lautenberg (D., N.J.) said the court's decision shows Congress should approve legislation he sponsored to give states, such as New Jersey, the ability to regulate solid waste processing facilities along rail lines.

"Our residents deserve better than to have a potential health hazard in their backyard," he said.

The northern New Jersey conflict began in January 2005, when Meadowlands Commission officials sought a task force to examine problems associated with the sites. Talks between the railway and the DEP later broke off, and the state fined New York Susquehanna & Western Railway Corp. $2.5 million for its four stations in Hudson County and ordered it to comply with the regulations.

The railway sued the DEP in August 2005, saying the fines could put it out of business. The fine was erased in February by U.S. District Judge Katharine S. Hayden.

Railway spokeswoman Melanie Boyer yesterday said in an e-mail that the Cooperstown, N.Y., railroad was studying the panel's ruling, which was issued Tuesday.

"It is our hope that, with the clarification of the law provided by this decision, it will serve as a basis for resolution of the issues with NJDEP [the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection]," she said.

Hayden had ruled that the garbage stations were subject to a federal law, the Interstate Commerce Commission Termination Act, and not the more stringent New Jersey environmental rules. The three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit disagreed.

"We hold that the Termination Act does not preempt state regulation if it is nondiscriminatory and not unreasonably burdensome," the panel found.

"Because it appears from this record that some, but not all, of the [state] regulations may meet this test, we vacate the district court's order permanently enjoining the state from enforcing the regulations, and remand for consideration of whether each regulation is preempted," the Philadelphia-based panel decided.

DEP Commissioner Lisa P. Jackson said she supported passage of the measure.

"These facilities must not, and should not, be exempt from environmental regulations. They can do real harm," Jackson said.

The trash transfer sites pose risks to air quality, because they can release dust laden with toxic particles, and water purity, which can be tainted by polluted runoff, Jackson said.

The case has attracted national attention, with Colorado, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, Pennsylvania and Vermont urging the panel to support New Jersey's position.

Inquirer staff writer Edward Colimore contributed to this article.