Skip to content

Voters not in the mood for bonds

This may be the worst year for bonds on ballots in two decades. Americans going to the polls on Nov. 2 will be asked to vote on, among other things, $16.8 billion in municipal bonds. Their answer, judging by e-mails I got on Gov. Christie's decision to cancel a new railroad tunnel under the Hudson River, will be: No, no, no, and no.

This may be the worst year for bonds on ballots in two decades.

Americans going to the polls on Nov. 2 will be asked to vote on, among other things, $16.8 billion in municipal bonds. Their answer, judging by e-mails I got on Gov. Christie's decision to cancel a new railroad tunnel under the Hudson River, will be: No, no, no, and no.

The people who write e-mails generally liked Christie's response to the tunnel, the cost of which is creeping higher and higher. New Jerseyans and non-New Jerseyans alike are saying no to more taxes, borrowing, and government.

The new negativity may extend to those bonds on the ballots, and that would be a big turnaround. The 2000s were a record decade for bond approvals, with voters passing almost $275 billion of them in November elections.

In terms of approval rates, that decade was second only to the 1980s, with voters saying yes about 81 percent of the time, compared with 83 percent in the 1980s. The worst decade for bond approvals was the 1970s, when voters passed about 49 percent.

The 2000s were the decade of home ownership, of the boom in the suburbs beyond the suburbs, as celebrated by New York Times columnist David Brooks in his book On Paradise Drive (2004). All those new communities needed roads and schools and sewers and ballparks, and the people who lived there approved bonds by the boatload.

Now a lot of those people have lost their properties to foreclosure, many of them are unemployed, and even more have seen their 401(k) retirement savings devastated. They're not feeling so expansive. No more borrowing!

The approval ratio on bonds has been declining for years now, though perhaps a little more slowly than most people thought it would. In 2006, voters approved 88.6 percent of the record $78.6 billion in new borrowing they were asked about. That fell to 83.7 percent in 2007, 82.1 percent in 2008, and 77.5 percent in 2009, according to Ipreo Holdings.

In the big picture, such expressions of fiscal restraint have little impact on the amount states and municipalities borrow, which has topped $400 billion in three of the past five years. Public officials long ago found ways to circumvent the finicky whims of the voters with such things as authority-issued revenue bonds and moral-obligation bonds.

But it's the thought that counts, and the thoughts are dark these days. The public is finally paying attention to public finance. If I were a mayor, I wouldn't champion the construction of a sports stadium or convention center right now.

People are especially paying attention to public employees' retirement plans, which some experts predict will bankrupt the nation. The public is also very concerned and surprised about the salaries made by everyone from government administrators to firefighters.

The backlash against state- and local-government workers probably began at some point last year, when people realized that, for all the talking politicians were doing about firing employees, they weren't following through. For their part, many of the unions representing these government workers proved tone-deaf and resistant to concessions.

That means the battle is joined. Shrinking government may be impossible at the federal level. At the state and local level, though, there's going to be a brawl.

In the meantime, voters will have their say on $16.8 billion in bonds. My bet is that the answer will be no, no, no, and no.

Joe Mysak is a Bloomberg News columnist. He can be reached at jmysakjr@bloomberg.net