Skip to content

Philadelphia City Council blocks Parker administration from contracting with Chester trash incinerator

The legislation advanced only allows for the city to contract with landfills, effectively blocking the city from using incineration to dispose of its trash.

City Councilmembers, from left, Kendra Brooks, Isaiah Thomas, Jamie Gauthier, and Rue Landau attend a rally outside City Hall early Thursday morning  Sept. 17, 2026 to where protesters called on Council to reject Mayor Cherelle L. Parker's waste disposal contracts. A coalition of elected officials, health and climate experts, and advocates from Philadelphia and Chester gathered to oppose the city’s sending its trash to an incinerator in Chester.
City Councilmembers, from left, Kendra Brooks, Isaiah Thomas, Jamie Gauthier, and Rue Landau attend a rally outside City Hall early Thursday morning Sept. 17, 2026 to where protesters called on Council to reject Mayor Cherelle L. Parker's waste disposal contracts. A coalition of elected officials, health and climate experts, and advocates from Philadelphia and Chester gathered to oppose the city’s sending its trash to an incinerator in Chester.Read moreTom Gralish / Staff Photographer

Philadelphia City Council members on Wednesday blocked Mayor Cherelle L. Parker’s administration from entering into a new, four-year contract with a controversial trash incinerator in Chester, a move that injects uncertainty into the city’s vast and complex trash disposal system.

The administration sought Council approval to ink a new deal with Reworld, the waste-to-energy facility where the city has for years sent about a third of its trash to be burned while the rest is sent to landfills.

However, Council’s Committee on the Environment on Wednesday voted unanimously to amend the Parker-backed legislation to remove Reworld from the proposed city contract. The legislation the committee advanced only allows for the city to contract with landfills, effectively blocking the city from using incineration to dispose of its trash.

“We have ended our practice of burning trash in Chester,” Councilmember Jamie Gauthier declared after the vote.

The amended legislation now advances to the full Council, where it could be voted on in the coming weeks.

The vote was the culmination of a yearslong effort by environmental and racial justice advocates who teamed up with Chester Mayor Stefan Roots and Gauthier to press the city to end its relationship with Reworld.

“It is our constitutional obligation to reject a deal that is bad for this city,” Gauthier said Wednesday during a hearing on the legislation that lasted more than five hours. “We’ve been clear for over a year now that we are not OK with the same toxic choices.”

Gauthier, Roots, and others have cited pollution that can cause adverse health effects for residents in the city to Philadelphia’s south. Last year, Gauthier authored legislation to ban the city from incinerating trash entirely, but she failed to garner support from a majority of Council members, and the bill was never called up for a vote.

Parker’s administration has advocated for the city to continue its existing contract with Reworld while it develops a long-term plan to move away from both incineration and landfills by reducing waste entirely.

“It is not a real solution to move it from an incinerator in Chester to landfills,” Managing Director Carlton Williams said Wednesday. “The real solution is … waste reduction, increased recycling, and better composting.”

And Reworld officials said that the pollutants emitted by the facility are below national quality thresholds, and that refusing to contract with the company would threaten jobs in the region.

“Today is about more than political differences,“ said John Scott, Reworld’s director of government relations. ”It’s about the hardworking men and women who provide essential services, the families who depend on those jobs, and Philadelphia’s long-term future.“

Williams said that moving away from incineration would cost taxpayers $15 million over the life of the contract.

The city’s current contract with Reworld runs out at the end of this year. It was unclear Wednesday if the Parker administration could continue to send trash to Reworld’s facility next year by using another contracting mechanism, such as extending its current contract without Council’s approval.

Joe Grace, a spokesperson for the mayor’s office, said only that the administration would “consider all options.”

Council members on Wednesday heard testimony from a variety of Philadelphia and Chester officials, as well as health experts, environmental advocates, and dozens of members of the public.

They also heard from Eric Bazis, a former Reworld employee who sued the company in 2024, saying that he was improperly fired after raising concerns about environmental compliance. That lawsuit is pending.

Council subpoenaed Bazis for testimony, and Reworld attorneys this week asked a city judge to nullify the subpoena, writing in court papers that it would be inappropriate for Bazis to testify given his ongoing litigation.

But a Common Pleas Court judge on Tuesday upheld Council’s subpoena, clearing the way for Bazis to testify, court records show.

Bazis told Council members on Wednesday that he learned during a 2023 meeting that higher-ups at Reworld were “gaming the system” by burning clean material during regulatory testing. He said that he raised concerns and that, shortly thereafter, he was suspended from his job and ultimately fired.

Attorneys for Reworld have previously said in filings that Bazis is a disgruntled former employee who was terminated for faking time sheets.

Councilmember Jim Harrity, a Democrat who represents the city at-large, said he was taken aback by Bazis’ testimony, saying during the hearing that what Bazis described “doesn’t even sound legal.”

Several other members of the committee signaled at the beginning of the hearing that they were leaning toward blocking the Parker administration from entering into a new contract with Reworld.

“There was never a convincing argument that took my attention off the health impacts,” said Councilmember Nicolas O’Rourke, a member of the progressive Working Families Party who represents the city at-large. “The administration will need some deeply, deeply compelling new information to convince me that trash incineration is remotely close to the right move.”

And Councilmember Nina Ahmad, a Democrat who also represents the city at-large, said at the start of the hearing that her goal was not merely to reduce the amount of trash that the city burns.

“I want that number to go to zero,” she said.