Skip to content

A Citizen's Letter to Congressman Joseph Pitts of PA: Will Pitts protect patients across the nation from FDA's "mission-corruption"?

Honorable Congressman Pitts,

I understand that your colleague, Congressmen Fitzpatrick of PA, has informed you about a severe nationwide public health hazard caused by the FDA's Center for Devices and Radiological Health (CDRH).

I also understand that as a chair of the House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Health, you have the capacity to efficiently catalyze a congressional inquiry to focus on the danger posed to patient safety by FDA's failures in the medical device regulatory arena.

Congressman, in 2011 this severe public safety hazard was taken to your colleagues in the Senate's HELP committee.

The problem was heard at a HELP committee hearing on November 15, 2011. But it was downplayed and ignored by the senate - specifically because industry lobby groups and a number of powerful US senators, including senator Al Franken, elected to put their states' economic interests before the health of the people across our nation.

That was a catastrophic regulatory error on the part of the 2011 congress - one which we know you will not repeat.

The majority of the 2011 HELP senators simply remained silent or absent in response to this serious safety warning from the Institute of Medicine (IOM).

This 2011 failure to act, was an unforgivable dereliction of congressional duty to the American people. Specifically, because it led to the death of many unsuspecting citizens of the United States.

 In October 2013, this senate committee's failure to act on the safety concerns raised by the IOM, translated into our family, and many others' across the nation, being devastated by a faulty but commonly used medical device.

This deadly failure was a direct result of CDRH "mission-corruption" and congressional failure to focus on protecting American patients.

As you know, congressman Fitzpatrick has now fully recognized this public health hazard and the 2011 senate's failure to act.

In a courageous move, Fitzpatrick presented himself, along with us, at FDA on 4/21/15 to announce his severe concern regarding the CDRH failure to protect people across our nation.

For the record, you may read congressman Fitzpatrick's personal remarks to the FDA workshop hearing on post-market medical device surveillance here.

You can view our own testimonies here and here.

Congressman Fitzpatrick and Mr. Rusk in his office, as well as Ms. Volante and Ms. Stirrup in your office, have been fully briefed on all angles of this issue.

On 4/21/15, Fitzpatrick pointedly, and on the record, demanded action aimed at correcting CDRH failures in protecting the American public from faulty medical devices. He has called for immediate House oversight of the FDA's CDRH by the House Energy and Commerce subcommittee on Health, which you chair.

Our point is clear-cut, Mr. Pitts. The FDA's CDRH is a "mission-corrupted" federal agency. It has compromised and harmed many unsuspecting Americans by equating industry interests with those of the American people - harmed, or in harm's way.

This agency's leadership and the federal legislation governing it, are failing the American public and have strayed quite far from their founding mission.

Congressman Pitts, we hope and expect, that given the clear and loud alarm raised by Congressmen Fitzpatrick, you and the House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Health, will powerfully rise to the occasion and look at this problem with the care and immediate due diligence it requires.

The 2015 House of Representatives cannot fail where the 2011 Senate's complacently failed to protect the American people. Or will you?

If you do not act immediately, more American lives and health insurance dollars will be compromised and lost to this "self-made" national health and economic security threat posed by our own federal agency - the FDA's CDRH.  

Congressman, this is your jurisdiction as the chairman of the subcommittee on Health to focus on.

Unsuspecting American Lives have truly been lost and remain at stake - not because of a foreign enemy, but due to a grievous failure in one of our own federal agencies. A failure you can quickly resolve from the House.

We look forward to hearing from you in the near future.

Yours with respect,

Hooman and Amy.

Hooman Noorchashm and Amy Reed, husband-and-wife physicians, have campaigned to ban electric morcellators since December 2013, soon after Reed's unsuspected uterine cancer was spread by the device during a routine hysterectomy.


Read more from the Check Up blog »