Skip to content

Will Congress choose to protect patients and doctors from dangerous devices?

On June 8, 2016, a bipartisan bill was proposed by U.S. Representatives Mike Fitzpatrick (R-PA), Louise Slaughter (D-NY) and Ryan Zinke (R-MT).

This bill, the "Medical Device Guardians Act" (H.R. 5404), was named in honor of the hundreds, if not thousands, of women whose lives were devastated or ended prematurely, using a flawed medical device known as a Power Morcellator.

 

The Guardians Act targets a very serious defect in the FDA's "self-reporting" requirements for medical devices.

Current law requires that hospital corporations and manufacturers report adverse outcomes related to the use of medical devices to FDA. In the case of the power morcellator, this legal requirement was not followed and lives were compromised for over two decades.

This bellwether failure is but one example of a dangerous disconnect between some practitioners and their hospital administrations and medical device manufacturers.

Why are physicians  not required to "self-report" device-related adverse outcomes as a matter of routine? After all, a doctor or practitioner using a medical device that causes a complication in a patient has the most accurate perspective on any dangers.

Wouldn't it make sense for the FDA to have access to such signals directly from doctors themselves?

The Guardians Act also protects physicians, by shielding them from civil liability in any malpractice cases that arise based on their reports.

This bill is a win-win that protects both patients and physicians. Plus, it codifies into law a specific  mandate of the American Medical Association's Code of Medical Ethics that doctors should be following anyway.

But the Guardians Act faces two potential threats.

First, medical device advocacy groups, like AdvaMed and MDMA are already objecting to this bill because it will uncover potential problems requiring work on the part of medical device companies to remedy. But, good stewardship requires that such advocacy groups keep patient safety at the forefront of their activities.

The second threat to The Guardians Act is congressional complacency and bad timing.

Without a question representatives Fitzpatrick, Slaughter, Zinke and a core group of other representatives have risen strongly to this cause. But, we have already seen some terrible resistance and lethargy in securing the medical device regulatory space from prominent members of Congress.

Additionally, with a break approaching quickly for Congress, and with Mr. Fitzpatrick in his last term in the House, the fate of the Guardians Act (H.R. 5404) remains very much in the balance.

The hazard in the medical device regulatory space in America is quite clear and well described. So whether Congress and the president choose to expedite this simple and common-sense legislative measure is a litmus test of their integrity as our representatives.

Let us hope that the House, the Senate and the president take note of the Guardians Act.

Agreeing on a non-political bill that will save American lives should be a no-brainer on the Hill.


Read more from the Check Up blog »