Skip to content

'Informed Consent' at Lantern Theater: Profound issues made trite

"Trace the genome — the greatest story ever told. We're all cousins!" With this gleeful announcement, an irritating genetic anthropologist named Jillian (Kittson O'Neill) launches Informed Consent, by Debora Zoe Laufer, an irritating play at the Lantern Theater about various "races for the cure."

This worst-case scenario about pitiless scientific research started from a true story — the tragic prevalence of diabetes among the Havasupai tribe who live in the Grand Canyon — and makes it into a trite exposé of the heartlessness of scientists.  The only good that comes of this contrived narrative is that the scientist is not rewarded, and thus we are spared more fraudulent self-serving explanations about saving humanity and the repulsive possibility of everyone's being able to literally live forever.

Jillian herself, ironically, lives under the hereditary doom of early-onset Alzheimer's, the dread disease that took her mother's life when she was 36. She is running out of time, especially since, contrary to all sense, she has a 4-year-old daughter, and she hopes to find a cure before this horror befalls her. Meanwhile she is offered a plum position to see whether she can help the Havasupai.

Ruthlessly trampling on the tribe's cultural life, she persuades them to give blood samples, despite their belief that blood is sacred. She will take her research in unauthorized directions, discovering their migratory patterns. This is a betrayal both of her mission and of their creation myth, that they sprang from the canyon itself.

The delegate from the tribe is Arella (Samantha Bowling, who also plays, with cloying cuteness, the 4-year old daughter). Arella's complicated moral dilemma is never sufficiently developed. Jillian's husband writes children's books. In  this role, Lindsay Smiling is the only sympathetic character in the bunch, although why he was so suddenly and powerfully attracted to Jillian made no sense to me.  Other characters are played by Justin Jain and Maria Konstantinidis, mostly as stereotypes and mostly for laughs.

According to the author's note in the program, Laufer based the play on a New York Times article. There is only one mention in the play of the beauty of the canyon itself, so I suspect Laufer has never been there. But I have — I hiked the canyon a few years ago, talked to some of the people who live there, and wrote a travel article for Oxygen magazine in which I said: "Havasu is called 'the gem of the Grand Canyon' for good reason: There is an oasis 10 miles down, with lush cottonwood trees and immense waterfalls and flowering cactus, walled in by dramatic red rock jutting into the bluest sky thousands of feet above you.  When night falls the blackest sky fills with a zillion stars.  This is what the world must have looked like before there was civilization — imagine somewhere between Jurassic Park and a Gauguin painting."

The sterility of Informed Consent is its own argument: A lab is not a canyon, crocodile tears are not sufficient regret for risking a child's life, and a play needs to be more than a gimmicky debate.

Through Feb. 12 at Lantern Theater, 10th & Ludlow Streets. Tickets: $10-$42. Information:  www.lanterntheater.org or 215-829-0395.