Skip to content

Prosecution wraps up case in kidnapping trial

After 11 days of hearing from prosecution witnesses, the defense began its case Tuesday in the trial of Christina Regusters, the day-care worker accused of kidnapping and sexually assaulting a 5-year-old girl taken last year from her West Philadelphia kindergarten class.

After 11 days of hearing from prosecution witnesses, the defense began its case Tuesday in the trial of Christina Regusters, the day-care worker accused of kidnapping and sexually assaulting a 5-year-old girl taken last year from her West Philadelphia kindergarten class.

Defense attorney W. Fred Harrison Jr. opened his case with a character witness: Latasha Moore, a sister of the accused who vouched for Regusters' reputation as a "law-abiding citizen."

Although prosecutors generally don't cross-examine character witnesses, Assistant District Attorney Erin O'Brien got Moore to acknowledge she did not live in Philadelphia in 2013 when Regusters allegedly kidnapped the child.

Harrison is to present additional character witnesses Wednesday, but it seems unlikely Regusters herself will testify.

Last week, Harrison persuaded Common Pleas Court Judge Jeffrey P. Minehart to suppress Regusters' statement to detectives on Feb. 14, 2013, the day she was arrested.

Minehart ruled detectives inadvertently failed to warn Regusters of her constitutional right to remain silent or have a lawyer present. The judge barred prosecutors from using the statement. If Regusters testifies, however, Minehart ruled, prosecutors may use the statement as rebuttal.

Minehart also told the jury of seven women and five men they would probably hear closing arguments Wednesday and, possibly, his legal instructions.

Much of Tuesday's court session was spent on a prosecution witness, Detective Daniel O'Malley of the police Special Victims Unit. O'Brien recalled O'Malley, who was the lead investigator, to recap hundreds of leads a task force followed before Regusters was arrested.

Harrison, in turn, spent almost 90 minutes questioning O'Malley to highlight the small amount of direct evidence detectives found that incriminates Regusters.

Prosecutors allege that Regusters is the woman disguised in full Muslim garb seen on surveillance video taking the girl from Bryant Elementary School on Jan. 14, 2013. Regusters worked at a day-care center across from Bryant where the girl was in an after-school program.

Regusters has denied involvement in the abduction, and Harrison has argued other relatives living with Regusters in a house in the 6200 block of Walton Avenue could have been involved.

With the victim unable to identify her abductor, the only evidence directly linking Regusters is her DNA found on a black T-shirt the child wore when she was found in an Upper Darby park before dawn Jan. 15, 2013.

The victim testified that a woman in Muslim garb took her from school to a strange house where she was blindfolded, kept naked under a bed, and sexually assaulted by a man she never saw or heard.

Early the next morning, the girl said, a teenager named "China" - Regusters' childhood nickname - woke her, gave her a black T-shirt to wear, and carried to a park and abandoned her.

jslobodzian@phillynews.com

215-854-2985 @joeslobo