Skip to content

N.J. judge backs law on health co-pays

Public workers must pay at least 1.5 percent of their salaries for care, she ruled.

TRENTON - A New Jersey judge ruled Thursday that a new law requiring public employees to pay at least 1.5 percent of their salaries toward health insurance can go into effect Friday, as scheduled.

Unions for police and firefighters had asked Superior Court Judge Linda Feinberg for a temporary restraining order that would have kept the law from taking effect - at least in some situations.

The request was part of a larger lawsuit that seeks to block the new law, which is part of the state's efforts to hold down costs by being tougher on public employees and their unions, including those working for local government.

The new law, championed by first-year Republican Gov. Christie and approved unanimously in March by a Democratic-controlled Legislature, requires the contributions of employees once their contracts expire. Many public employees already contribute at least 1.5 percent of their salaries to health coverage. The unions say some locals have chosen smaller pay raises to keep the free health care, or have switched to inferior insurance coverage to keep it free.

Feinberg sided with the state in every key issue as she ruled from the bench Thursday, following more than two hours of courtroom arguments.

The unions' main contention was that the amount employees pay for their health insurance should be worked out in contract negotiations - not imposed by the state.

"Not every term and condition on which a collective bargaining unit would want to negotiate is fair play," Feinberg said.

She also rejected the unions' arguments that the law amounts to an unfair tax on the state's roughly 400,000 public employees, or that the law was vague.

The unions will get another chance to make their case in court later. But they'll do so knowing that one judge has already found the case is not likely to succeed on its merits.

While the unions ultimately hope to stop the law from being enforced entirely, the main concern on Thursday was narrow. Police and firefighters are prohibited by state law from going on strike. When their contract talks reach impasses, they go to a lengthy arbitration process.

The public safety unions said the 1.5 percent payment requirement should not apply to the 215 local unions currently in that process.

The New Jersey State Policeman's Benevolent Association issued a statement Thursday saying the group was disappointed the ruling did not clear up any confusion in how the law should be interpreted.

Meanwhile, Christie spoke to the state's branch of AARP, criticizing the unions for trying to block the law.

"They are in front of a judge today asking if they can pay nothing," he said. "We have to impose discipline on government. Left unconstrained, government will continue to spend."