Skip to content

The banality of evil in a Pa. borough budget | Will Bunch Newsletter

Plus, Laquan McDonald won’t be voting for Rahm Emanuel in ‘28.

It’s never too early to start giving thanks — for all the voters who endured long lines to cast their history-altering ballots from Mississippi to Maine, for the sisters whose elder-care labors needed a Saturday Night Live sketch to get nationally recognized, or to the Sullivan family out of Northeast Philly for having that fourth kid. This is my way of saying there’s no newsletter next week. Happy Thanksgiving, everyone.

If someone forwarded you this email, sign up for free here.

How ‘blood money’ from ICE is helping towns balance their books

The recent headline on the website of Carlisle’s Sentinel newspaper could best be described as banal: “Mount Holly proposes no tax increase as ICE payments flow into borough funds.”

Taxes are stable in Mount Holly Springs, Pa., a small borough of 2,333 people in Cumberland County, about 25 miles southwest of Harrisburg. Federal dollars are flowing into the municipality’s bank account thanks to its partnership with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) under a program known as 287(g). Life sounds good...

...Except, of course, for at least 34 immigrants, many of them driving essential goods through central Pennsylvania, who’ve been arrested by the four-person police force in Mount Holly Springs since March and turned over to ICE for detention in squalid facilities like the Moshannon Valley Processing Center, with the ultimate goal of placing them in shackles and flying them out of the United States for good.

The mid-20th century writer and philosopher Hannah Arendt famously coined the phrase “the banality of evil” as she sought to explain the humanitarian abuses that took place in Germany after she’d fled Nazi rule in the 1930s. She argued that bureaucrats and functionaries didn’t ponder the moral consequences of their actions but saw themselves merely as cogs in a system, with a “reluctance ever to imagine what the other person is experiencing.”

Arendt could have been writing about Mount Holly Springs or hundreds of other small towns or counties where federal dollars for arresting immigrants, breaking apart their families, and terrifying their neighbors has become just a civic budget line item to avoid tax increases or allow a tiny hamlet to keep its local cops well equipped.

At the recent borough council meeting where the Mount Holly Springs annual budget was reviewed, Tom Day — who is both police chief and borough manager — said that, other than $10,000 for bulletproof vests, the initial $130,000 windfall from the Donald Trump regime for apprehending immigrants under 287(g) is sitting in the bank. Monthly cash payments averaging $1,000 are helping the tiny locality balance its books, he explained.

Yet not all of this sits well with a band of local critics of the police partnership with ICE, including council member Pam Still, who worry not just about the potential legal liability from the arrest surge in Mount Holly Springs but also the moral tradeoffs.

“Mount Holly Springs should not be doing the federal government’s work,” Still told me by phone Monday night. “It’s disruptive to the town. People are upset. I’ve had so many people say to me, ‘It’s blood money,’ that it feels like blood money.”

Yet Mount Holly Springs is just the tip of ICE’s financial iceberg as the feds dole out several billion dollars to local law-enforcement agencies willing to deputize officers to assist them in striving towards Trump’s mass-deportation goal of arresting as many as 3,000 immigrants from coast to coast every day.

Pennsylvania, where at least 146 law-enforcement agencies — most in counties that voted for Trump, most coming on board in the last year as the financial incentives were added — have now partnered with ICE, is on the cutting edge of a national debate over local cops making immigration busts. Neighboring states — including New York, New Jersey and Maryland — have banned 287(g) pacts on the argument that immigrants’ fear of the police would make their communities less safe.

In Sunbelt states such as Florida and Texas, where the program thrives with state-level encouragement or mandates, the financial arrangement that ICE critics call “blood money” has become a substantial source of income. Last month, the Wall Street Journal published a story detailing how 287(g) has become “a cash cow” for rural spots like Doddridge County, W. Va., which took in $137,000 to buy a new police car for a community with few if any immigrants.

I’d argue that the Wall Street Journal perspective is not wrong — the ICE initiative is a waste of tax dollars, at a time when the outdated routers that keep our jetliners aloft are melting down — yet gives a wrong impression. The problem with 287(g) — named for the section of a 1996 immigration law that authorized it — is not that too few folks are getting arrested for all that money, but too many.

Democratic U.S. Rep. Chris Deluzio, who represents a stretch of western Pennsylvania west and north of Pittsburgh, issued a report last week that found that more than half of the 209 recent ICE arrests in his district were made by local cops under 287(g), and that 140 of those apprehended had no criminal record.

“Remember, ICE is now the most funded law enforcement agency in the country,” Deluzio said in a news conference last week. “And what are they doing with this power? Endangering America’s lives and liberties. Making our communities less safe.”

In the community of Mount Holly Springs, the police chief Day did respond to my email for comment but largely to criticize my earlier column on the 287(g) program there, which he called “a story to fit my agenda.” He continues to insist that the primary goal of the borough’s immigration enforcement is to improve truck safety by stopping “drivers that cannot understand the signage,” and noted that the Chinese human rights lawyer and asylum seeker caught up in the dragnet, Wu Shaoping, is now a free man, with his traffic charges dismissed.

It was the July arrest of Wu, who was cited for running a stop sign while making Amazon deliveries, handed over to a nearby ICE agent, and detained for 10 days, that first led me to Mount Holly Springs to investigate the ugly realities of 287(g). His case put a human face on a program that police and local officials prefer to keep as a boring budget line item, deflecting requests for meaningful information.

Still told me that local activists have been filing Right-to-Know requests in an effort to understand how Day and his three officers are running the program. She said one partially blacked out report detailed the arrest of two undocumented immigrants who were passengers in a broken-down car, with a child in the back — arrests that, just like that of Wu, had nothing to do with the chief’s “truck safety” agenda.

As has been the case in other localities, the growing controversy over ICE cooperation has also threatened public information and open debate. At the same meeting where Mount Holly Springs council members discussed the budget, a resolution that would restrict public comment, including a ban on out-of-town speakers and the possibility of arrest for attendees who don’t comply, was debated but put on hold.

Deluzio, in his report, agreed that one of the biggest problems with the 287(g) program is that the data that has been released to the taxpayers funding Trump’s mass-deportation push is faulty and grossly incomplete. The congressman hopes the new Democratic-led Congress can address that, and do even more.

“The Congress now, with a new Democratic majority, I think will want to put a stop to the overfunding and abuses under ICE, and that accountability will come,” he said. Perhaps, although doing that, and clawing back some of the ungodly $250 billion or so that this GOP-led Congress has thrown at ICE, will surely face Trump’s veto pen what with white supremacist Stephen Miller all but running the White House.

A better hope would be for the new Democratic trifecta in Harrisburg to put its newfound powers to use, and simply follow the lead of our progressive neighbors and ban 287(g) programs across the state.

Police chief Day was exactly right about one thing: This opinion writer does have an agenda. I want to see local cops actually making their communities safer, which would mean not leaving our immigrant neighbors so fearful that they are terrified to go outside or report actual crimes, lest a broken headlight or a missed stop sign ends their freedom and puts them in shackles.

I’d love to see the banality of evil removed from the borough council agenda.

Yo, do this!

  1. There’s a reason that Rachel Maddow’s Monday night appearances on MS Now have become appointment TV, and it’s not because she delivers the news. Maddow’s one weird trick is her storytelling ability. I’m happy to report that it is on full display in her brand new book, The Department of Fate: The Promise, the Power, and the Collapse of America’s Most Consequential Institution, which tells the complicated history of the U.S. Department of Justice since its inception in 1870. That might not sound exciting, but Maddow brings a broader tale of occasional do-gooding corrupted by power and greed to life, through dramatic clashes like the 1871 war on the KKK and the 1894 Pullman strike. A compelling read (or, in my case, listen).

  2. This past week’s communications breakdowns have taken the edge off the post-election giddiness in anti-Trump world. We still need a good laugh from somewhere. Thank God for Philomena Cunk. The latest in a series of Netflix-streaming mockumentaries that I was tragically unaware of until this weekend, Cunk on Cinema, is a deadpan romp (the fictional Cunk is brilliantly portrayed by British actress Diane Morgan) that offers a sort of drunk — or at least buzzed — history of more than a century of motion pictures. You might even learn a new thing or two if you can stop laughing.

Ask me anything

Question: Given Republican anger at Biden’s pardons and Democratic anger at Trump’s, could there be sufficient bipartisan support for an amendment to limit pardon power to overcome the extreme difficulty of constitutional amendments? Is it a worthwhile anti-corruption measure? — Richard Robbins (@richnyc.bsky.social) via Bluesky

Answer: I received so many great questions this week, which says a lot about the revolutionary moment we are living in. Richard’s query is something I’ve been pondering a lot, as Trump and his cronies have made a mockery of the ancient concept of clemency by springing all their crooked friends (or paying clients) from behind bars. The Founders made a bunch of well-intentioned mistakes in writing the Constitution, although it’s weird that the likes of James Madison and Alexander Hamilton were smart enough to fear a man on a white horse but didn’t realize how easily pardons could be abused by a rogue president. You make a good argument: Cite the pardons by Biden or Bill Clinton to argue the whole system has turned rotten. Undoing this mess will be hard, but it must be attempted.

What you’re saying about...

It’s hardly a surprise that newsletter readers are solidly behind the campaign to replace New York’s Chuck Schumer as Democratic leader when the party takes over the Senate in January, and that most would prefer Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen, who has emerged as chief rival. “Definitely replace him and all the old white men,” wrote Ginger Osborne. “Bring on the young people. The Democratic party needs many shots in the arm. I say this as a white woman who will turn 76 in 8 days.” But Stephen Rourke thinks Schumer has the votes, this time. “I see Van Hollen as mounting a challenge to Schumer’s leadership but settling for being his whip, allowing Schumer to retire at the end of his current term (in 2028) and replacing him at that point,” he suggested.

📮 This week’s question: The flights are finally back to normal, but the blame game is just beginning for the air-traffic meltdown last Friday that stranded thousands of travelers. Do we agree that it’s poor management from Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and the Trump regime, or do they have a point in blaming the Biden administration or Congress? Are bigger forces, including AI, in the mix? Please email me your answer and put the exact phrase “Blame for air meltdown” in the subject line.

Backstory on why Rahm Emanuel can never be POTUS

Rahm Emanuel, who served as Chicago’s mayor during much of the 2010s and has been a congressman, a White House chief of staff, and an ambassador, is apparently running for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2028, according to at least 10 different mainstream news organizations that keep telling me this, again and again.

I’m here to remind you about one of Emanuel’s former Chicago constituents who won’t be voting for him in the Illinois primary less than two years from now: Laquan McDonald. He would have been 30 on Primary Day — had he not been murdered on Oct. 20, 2014 by a white Chicago police officer named Jason Van Dyke, who fired 16 shots into a Black teenager’s body even as McDonald, then 17, appeared to be walking away and then as he writhed on the pavement in agony. I can write “murdered” because something happened to Van Dyke that you rarely see in America: A jury convicted the now ex-cop of second-degree murder.

So justice was done? Yes, and no. On the “no” side of the ledger, Van Dyke was released after just three years in prison — less than half his sentence. But more importantly, his case may have never have gone to trial at all. For 13 agonizing months, even as thousands of angry Chicagoans marched through the streets, the city’s Emanuel administration refused to release the key evidence: a police dashcam video that showed what really happened. The delay meant the city’s official response was that McDonald was shot only after he “lunged” at officers with a small knife in his possession. That was a complete fiction.

Emanuel insisted throughout the 13 months and afterward that a) he’d never seen the video while its release was blocked and b) that the city’s hands were tied because of a U.S. Justice Department investigation. There’s no way of knowing if the first claim is true, but it was reported that DOJ had no issue with releasing the footage. Meanwhile, Emanuel was seeking reelection and locked in a tight runoff race with future U.S. Rep. Jesús “Chuy” García — an effort that might have faltered if the evidence of a police murder and coverup had emerged.

In April 2015, Emanuel administration lawyers agreed to a $5 million settlement with the McDonald family — even though the teen’s survivors hadn’t yet filed a lawsuit — that included a gag order that kept the video under wraps for months, until the mayor was on his way to a new term. “The idea that the mayor of Chicago would make the city pay $5 million to preemptively settle this case — including a provision that the dashcam video is to remain confidential — without having seen the video himself strikes me as extraordinarily difficult to believe,” Bernard Harcourt, a Chicago law professor, told the Guardian in December 2015, after a county judge finally ordered the video’s release.

There were calls for Emanuel to resign, and when he finally did leave office in 2018 his approval rating of 32% was lower than Donald Trump’s is today. This information can all be found in a nanosecond with a Google search, and yet to the nattering nabobs of Beltway political journalism, Emanuel’s shameful past is buried like ancient hieroglyphics. One outstanding journalist, however, is Heather Cherone of Chicago’s PBS station, who’s noted 10 fawning media profiles of Emanuel and his presidential prospects as “a radical centrist” (as the Wall Street Journal called him this week) that have made no mention of the McDonald murder and coverup.

Look, there is A LOT to loathe about an Emanuel presidential candidacy — the American Prospect calling him “Wall Street’s favorite Democrat,” his history of supporting mass incarceration and welfare cuts, his annoyingly abrasive personality, etc., etc. That’s a column I’ll probably never have to write because it’s clear on social media that the regular folks who vote in Democratic primaries hate him as much as I do.

But the continued journalistic fluffing of Emanuel and his doomed White House bid is both inexplicable and inexcusable. Maybe it’s fun to expense $80 steaks at the Capital Grill with Rahm and make fun of the dirty hippies who want to raise your taxes and integrate your kid’s elite school. But to dare to call yourself a journalist when you’re too lazy or ignorant or morally corrupt not to mention “Laquan McDonald” in your article that rises from the putrid cigar smoke...that’s beyond shameful.

What I wrote on this date in 2020

There’s two reasons why I’ve been returning to 2020 so often in this feature. One is that is was such a momentous year, but the other is that the dates that are Tuesdays in 2026 were also newsletter Tuesdays six years ago! On Nov. 17, 2020, I was pondering the imminent departure of Donald Trump from the White House, and how much his retirement plan of nonstop media attention and running for office yet again looked like Philly’s own Frank Rizzo. I wrote that " in the spirit of series like House of Cards or Veep, the White House was just the middle of a story arc — maybe Season 3 or 4 — in a production that will unfortunately keep getting renewed even as the show gets both lousier and more implausible (just like House of Cards!)." Ugh, how right that was. Read the rest: “How Trump became all of America’s Frank Rizzo.”

Recommended Inquirer reading

  1. Only one column last week as I attempted to grind my way through some investigative reporting. In that piece, I looked at the scariest Friday the 13th in American history — especially, but not limited to, the meltdown in nationwide air traffic — and what that told us about enduring more than two more years of the Trump regime. As with today’s newsletter, I invoked the late great Hannah Arendt, with her explanation that incompetence is a feature and not a bug in authoritarian governments. The new Congress can reject Trump’s bad appointees, but it can’t force him to pick good people.

  2. Every few days here in Philadelphia comes a jarring reminder that, for all the focus on the mess down in D.C., the struggles of managing and sometimes mismanaging the poorest big city in America come with life-or-death consequences. When a 10-year-old girl named Malayshia Allford went missing and eventually was discovered dead in the car trunk of her foster mom, a Philadelphia school teacher, The Inquirer didn’t let the story come and go as just another breaking news alert. We published a guest essay calling for an overhaul that would end the broken system of foster care as we know it, as well as an in-depth investigation of what went so wrong for Malayshia’s tragically short life. And we’re not done. I wish more cities and small towns had the people and the resources to cover what matters to the community. You support this mission in Philly when you subscribe to The Inquirer.

By submitting your written, visual, and/or audio contributions, you agree to The Inquirer’s Terms of Use, including the grant of rights in Section 10.

About our columnists

In contrast to news reporters, who operate within an independent, nonpartisan framework, columnists are charged with including their perspectives, opinions, and viewpoints when presenting their reporting. Inquirer columnists include Jenice Armstrong, Will Bunch, Luis F. Carrasco, Paul Davies, Daniel Pearson, Trudy Rubin, and Sabrina Vourvoulias.

Inquirer logo

Sign up for the Will Bunch Newsletter

Weekly

Go beyond the column with an email from me delving into the latest headlines, plus insight into what I’m reading, watching, and listening to.