Skip to content

Kelly downplays importance of arm strength in QBs

The Eagles quarterback competition would be easier to unravel if it was determined based on arm strength. Michael Vick, for whatever criticism he has endured, still throws a ball that looks different from those of the other quarterbacks on the roster.

Chip Kelly directs his team during NFL football practice at the Eagles' training facility, Tuesday, June 4, 2013, in Philadelphia. (Matt Rourke/AP file)
Chip Kelly directs his team during NFL football practice at the Eagles' training facility, Tuesday, June 4, 2013, in Philadelphia. (Matt Rourke/AP file)Read more

The Eagles quarterback competition would be easier to unravel if it was determined based on arm strength. Michael Vick, for whatever criticism he has endured, still throws a ball that looks different from those of the other quarterbacks on the roster.

But arm strength is not a determining factor. In fact, Chip Kelly said in April that too much emphasis is sometimes placed on arm strength when judging a quarterback.

"Sometimes the arm strength aspect of it is overrated because people are trying to paint it with a brush," Kelly said, responding to a question about Matt Barkley's arm strength. "We're not trying to knock over milk cartons at a county fair. It's about if you can put the ball in the right spot at the right time."

Still, the quarterback needs a strong enough arm to utilize the skill-position players the Eagles have assembled.

Vick's left arm has been praised for its strength since he starred at Virginia Tech more than a decade ago.

Nick Foles arrived in Philadelphia last season known as a strong-armed quarterback. He was inconsistent, but when his mechanics were sound, he showed why Andy Reid and Marty Mornhinweg were intrigued by him in the 2012 draft.

Then there's Barkley, whose arm strength was never considered elite. Kelly, offensive coordinator Pat Shurmur, and quarterbacks coach Bill Lazor each independently praised Barkley's arm as NFL-capable.

"When you have a strong arm you can attack all areas of the field," Vick said. "But we've got multiple quarterbacks with strong arms, so I don't think that's the determining factor. I think you've just got to make good decisions with the football. That's what's most important."

Hard to measure

When Vick was at his best with the Eagles in 2010, he was especially proficient on deep passes. On passes more than 20 yards that season, he was 27 for 65 (41.5 percent) for 1,013 yards, eight touchdowns, and five interceptions, according to Pro Football Focus.

Deep passes are not always a conclusive indicator of arm strength, either, because components of a strong-armed passer are velocity and the rotation on the ball. But it's one metric that can be compared, and Vick and Foles were average on passes of more than 20 yards last season. Vick was 13 for 40 (32.5 percent) for 414 yards, four touchdowns, and two interceptions. Foles was 10 for 28 (35.7 percent) for 291 yards, four touchdowns, and two interceptions.

By comparison, New England's Tom Brady was 31 for 94 (32.9 percent) for 1,023 yards, 10 touchdowns, and four interceptions. Green Bay's Aaron Rodgers was 21 for 72 (29.2 percent) for 980 yards, 12 touchdowns, and three interceptions.

When Foles relieved Vick in Week 10 last season, he completed an impressive 44-yard touchdown pass to Jeremy Maclin. Foles was on the run, stopped, set his feet, and threw a perfect spiral to Maclin in the end zone.

Five weeks later, Foles underthrew a pass to Maclin by three yards and it was intercepted. The wobbly pass came out of Foles' hands incorrectly, and he was unequivocal that it was a pass he could ably complete.

On the day after that game, Reid said Foles has "one of the stronger arms we've had [in Philadelphia], one of the stronger arms in the league." Reid then added that there's more that goes into throwing an effective deep ball than arm strength, saying that the feet must be set and the drop must be right. Those were elements that Foles needed to refine.

Foles' arm looked especially strong during the spring minicamps. He even completed a touchdown pass to DeSean Jackson that traveled 65 yards in the air.

"I feel like [my arm is] even stronger now just training, nutrition, everything," Foles said. "I think that your arm can get stronger. And there are going to be days when your arm doesn't feel as sharp as it usually does. You have to have a strong foundation in your legs to really get the ball out there sometimes. And sometimes your arm just feels like you can flick it a mile. Right now my arm feels good."

Confident in Barkley

Barkley may not have a reputation as a strong-armed quarterback, but his deep-ball statistics tell otherwise. During his final two seasons at Southern Cal, he completed 40.8 percent of his passes of more than 20 yards for 24 touchdowns, according to ESPN. That was a better percentage than Robert Griffin III and more touchdowns than Andrew Luck.

It doesn't mean Barkley has the strongest arm, but the Eagles are confident it's a capable arm. Kelly said there are "big, strong guys that can just sling the ball," but that Barkley is more of a "passer."

"You don't throw for over 10,000 yards and just get lucky a lot," Shurmur said. "I think his arm is strong enough to do what he needs to do, no question."

And "strong enough" might be an appropriate qualifier in this Eagles quarterback competition. Other attributes such as accuracy and decision-making will carry more weight than arm strength. But how heavily Kelly rates this "overrated" attribute could play a factor in who starts on Sept. 9.

Eagles Training Camp Schedule

Here is how the Eagles will prepare for the 2013 season, which begins for the Birds at 7:10 Sept. 9 at the Redskins. Tickets are still available for the five public practices at Lincoln Financial Field. Seating will be general admission by section with an eight-ticket limit per practice. Go to PhiladelphiaEagles.com to order or for more information:

July 22: Rookies report to NovaCare

July 23: 12:30 rookie practice - NovaCare

July 24: 12:30 rookie practice - NovaCare

July 25: Full team reports to NovaCare

July 26: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

July 27: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

July 28: 12:30 PUBLIC practice - Lincoln Financial Field

July 29: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

July 30: Day off

July 31: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 1: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 2: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 3: Day off

Aug. 4: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 5: 12:30 PUBLIC practice - Lincoln Financial Field

Aug. 6: 12:30 practice with New England Patriots - NovaCare

Aug. 7: 12:30 practice with New England Patriots - NovaCare

Aug. 8: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 9: 7:30 , New England Patriots at Eagles

Aug. 10: Day off

Aug. 11: 12:30 PUBLIC practice - Lincoln Financial Field

Aug. 12: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 13: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 14: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 15: 7:30 , Carolina Panthers at Eagles

Aug. 16: Day off

Aug. 17: 12:30 PUBLIC practice - Lincoln Financial Field (Time may change to 8:15 a.m. if Phillies game gets time change)

Aug. 18: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 19: Day off

Aug. 20: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 21: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 22: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 23: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 24: 7:30 , Eagles at Jacksonville Jaguars

Aug. 25: Day off

Aug. 26: 12:30 PUBLIC practice - Lincoln Financial Field

Aug. 27: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 28: 12:30 practice - NovaCare

Aug. 29: 7 p.m., Eagles at New York Jets

EndText

Contact Zach Berman
at zberman@phillynews.com. Follow on Twitter @ZBerm.
Join The Conversation