As states lose OB-GYNs, some look to limit medical malpractice risk
Since 2025, at least four states have enacted laws capping the damages to be awarded in medical malpractice cases or shortening the timeline for filing litigation.

States struggling to retain obstetricians and keep hospital labor and delivery units open are starting to limit medical malpractice lawsuits, their response to a crisis triggered by costly malpractice insurance, federal funding cuts, and, in some cases, abortion bans that restrict the care doctors can provide.
Since 2025, at least four states have enacted laws capping the damages to be awarded in medical malpractice cases or shortening the timeline for filing litigation. While those laws generally don’t focus on a specific medical field, proponents told KFF Health News they believed the changes would help address maternity care shortages.
The measures often passed with little fanfare, and patient advocates warn that they impose more of a burden on families harmed by an adverse outcome during childbirth.
Other critics say such legislation ignores alternative ways to retain obstetricians — such as addressing abortion rights, which several states pursued in this month’s midterm elections.
In Virginia, for one, voters approved a constitutional amendment that not only protects abortion rights but bars the state from prosecuting physicians who perform the procedure. Missouri voters upheld abortion rights in their state constitution, and Nevada voters added them.
But in deep-red Idaho, which had lost more than a third of its OB-GYNs two years after its near-total abortion ban took effect in 2022, voters rejected a proposal to restore access to the procedure. That left in place a law putting doctors at risk of prison time for providing a pregnant patient with lifesaving care.
States that severely restrict abortion, such as Idaho and Arkansas, are among those with the fewest maternity care providers relative to their population of women of reproductive age. In 2025, Arkansas limited malpractice claims stemming from childbirth to five years; other claims involving children can still be filed until a minor’s 11th birthday or two years postinjury, whichever is later.
“A lot of these small rural hospitals will tell you they can’t afford to recruit OBs,” said Arkansas state Rep. Aaron Pilkington, a Republican who co-sponsored that legislation. “Whatever you can do to just decrease the cost in recruiting them and paying for that malpractice insurance for a little bit, you know, to us, it was a worthwhile pursuit.”
Oklahoma and New Mexico recently capped certain types of damages. Oklahoma, where abortion is illegal, limited the amount that can be awarded for bodily injuries. New Mexico, where abortion is legal, targeted punitive damages — intended to address wrongdoing beyond financial losses — and raised the standard of proof for those damages to require “clear and convincing” evidence.
And in Utah, where OB-GYNs have raised concerns about recruitment and retention because of lawmakers’ attempts to prohibit abortion, the legislature passed malpractice protections shielding healthcare providers’ personal assets and calculating economic damages based on what patients paid rather than what they owed. The bill’s sponsor, Republican state Rep. Katy Hall, said liability insurance costs were driving doctors out of state, the Deseret News reported.
Medical malpractice lawsuits against OB-GYNs are common in the United States; childbirth can carry high risk and serious consequences. As a result, hospital administrators say, malpractice insurance costs for those doctors are higher than for many other specialties.
Facilities with labor and delivery units also face intense pressure points given looming cuts to Medicaid, which covered roughly 40% of births in 2024. Though most of the cuts, under the Trump administration’s One Big Beautiful Bill, won’t take full effect until 2027 or later, some hospitals have already cited them in closing labor and delivery units.
“We’re seeing practices bought up by private equity and hospital systems because there are these compounding financial pressures on practices,” said Rachel Gandell Tetlow, vice president of government and political affairs for the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. The group supported the medical malpractice bill that became law in New Mexico.
Rural hospitals have especially thin operating margins, according to the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform, a policy center that tracks rural hospital closures. The group has counted more than 140 rural hospitals that have stopped delivering babies or plan to stop from the end of 2020 through this year.
Arkansas is a prime example. Fewer than a third of counties had a birthing hospital as of July, according to the policy nonprofit Arkansas Center for Health Improvement.
In the southeastern corner of the state, the Mainline Health Monticello Clinic can be packed with pregnant patients by morning. Some drive more than an hour for their appointments. The clinic — a federally qualified health center protected by law from many medical malpractice claims — provides prenatal care for patients planning to deliver at the county’s only birthing hospital, Baptist Health Medical Center-Drew County.
Pilkington expects that the law limiting malpractice claims will help other rural hospitals to retain and staff their delivery units. The legislator said Arkansas has had only one birth injury lawsuit in the past decade — why he believes the law won’t significantly burden patients.
State Rep. Ashley Hudson, a Democrat and another co-sponsor, said she supported the bill because it expands maternal care provisions, including new Medicaid coverage for prenatal services and remote monitoring. Yet she’s skeptical that limiting malpractice cases will help recruit healthcare workers.
“We wonder why we can’t attract providers to come into the state,” Hudson said, all while passing laws “second-guessing” OB-GYNs’ ability to treat their patients.
Joanne Doroshow, executive director of the Center for Justice and Democracy at New York Law School, acknowledged that liability insurance is a genuine cost for hospitals and doctors but said capping what patients can recover doesn’t lower those premiums.
“We know what can actually help doctors with their insurance rates. It’s got nothing to do with stripping away the rights of patients,” she said. “It has to do with accountability through the regulatory system, through the government that oversees the insurance industry that is allowing these companies to be price gouging.”
For families dealing with adverse consequences connected with childbirth, trauma and loss can be acute. Narrowing their ability to seek compensation adds more pain, said Deirdre Dickson-Gilbert, founder and national director of the National Medical Malpractice Advocacy Association.
“You really don’t know what you need to be looking for. You just know that you’re hurting,” she said. “And by the time you find out, the statutes of limitation are over.”
When Anyssa Zancanella’s water broke during a family vacation near Salt Lake City, the 19-year-old expected better care there than she could get back home in rural Rock Springs, Wyo., where many patients are flown out for emergency treatment.
Instead, a crisis unfolded. Staff at Jordan Valley Medical Center kept raising her doses of Pitocin, a drug that strengthens contractions, even as a monitor recorded mounting fetal distress. Nearly 12 hours elapsed, with Zancanella ultimately undergoing an emergency cesarean section.
According to court records, baby Azaylee was born with severe brain damage because of the complications of that delivery. In her first five years, Zancanella said, the medical bills exceeded $1 million. Even today, she remains nonverbal and suffers from seizures. Her mother takes her monthly to Salt Lake City for specialized care.
Steward Health Care, a Dallas-based for-profit health system that owned the hospital at the time, was found liable last year for gross medical negligence in the case and ordered to pay Zancanella and her daughter $951 million. While battling the family’s lawsuit, the health system sold the facility and subsequently filed for bankruptcy. The nearly $1 billion judgment was entered by default in 2025.
Steward did not respond to a request for comment for this article. The hospital where Azaylee was born, now named Holy Cross Hospital-Jordan Valley West, still offers labor, delivery, recovery, and postpartum care.
The malpractice law that legislators passed last year didn’t affect Zancanella’s award because it didn’t target punitive damages, which Utah does not cap. A bankruptcy court will now determine what the mother and child ultimately receive, and Doroshow cautioned that verdicts such as theirs are “rarely, if ever, being paid fully.”
“This notion that hospitals are going under, or doctors are somehow going bankrupt because of jury awards,” she said, “that’s clearly not true.”
























