Skip to content

Temple hospital says strikers rejected promising offer

Temple University Hospital's interim chief executive officer said Wednesday that the union representing Temple's striking nurses and allied professionals summarily rejected a mediator proposal that, if accepted, would have been taken back to management for review.

Temple University Hospital's interim chief executive officer said Wednesday that the union representing Temple's striking nurses and allied professionals summarily rejected a mediator proposal that, if accepted, would have been taken back to management for review.

"The mediator offered what I'll call a mediator-proposed settlement to both sides," Sandy Gomberg said. "If PASNAP had agreed to those terms, the Temple negotiating team would have found them acceptable and brought it back to management."

The union said there was no mediator-proposed settlement at Wednesday's meeting between the two sides - simply a Temple management proposal conveyed through the mediator.

"Those same proposals had been floated to me the day before by Bob" Birnbrauer, the hospital's chief negotiator, said Bill Cruice, executive director of the Pennsylvania Association of Staff Nurses and Allied Professionals.

The union plans a rally at City Hall at 9 a.m. Thursday.

The union represents 1,000 nurses and 500 therapists, social workers, technicians, and health-care professionals that went on strike March 31 after working six months under the terms of a contract that had expired Sept. 30.

"Because Temple awkwardly painted itself into a corner by making a final offer, they have to save face by saying it's a mediator proposal," Cruice said.

Gomberg said the proposal removed the anti-disparagement clause that the nurses and other professionals complained would stifle their ability to speak up on behalf of their patients.

She said the union's rejection of the plan despite the removal of the anti-disparagement clause proves the strike is based on economic issues.

The hospital did bend on weekend differential pay and also agreed to have contracts for the union's two bargaining units - the nurses and allied professionals - expire at the same time. Initially, management sought a three-year contract for one group and a four-year contract for the other.

Management did not change its proposal for wages, nor did it change its proposed three-tiered structure for health benefits. The proposal also did not include funding for a tuition benefit for dependents, a longtime perk valued by the members.

"Hospitals and businesses - year-to-year and decade-to-decade - continue to change their benefit structure, their health insurance, their wage base, their pension plan," Gomberg said about the tuition benefit. "It's no different than any other benefit change in this economy."

The union came down to 3 percent per year for its wage proposal.

No new talks have been scheduled.

Contact staff writer Jane M. Von Bergen at 215-854-2769 or jvonbergen@phillynews.com.