Skip to content

Airgas letters show a softened position

The board of Airgas Inc. has not officially begun negotiating the company's sale to hostile suitor Air Products & Chemicals Inc., but a recent exchange of letters is starting to look like bargaining.

The board of Airgas Inc. has not officially begun negotiating the company's sale to hostile suitor Air Products & Chemicals Inc., but a recent exchange of letters is starting to look like bargaining.

Airgas chairman John van Roden told Air Products chairman and chief executive John E. McGlade in a letter Tuesday that the Airgas board "has unanimously concluded that it believes that the value of Airgas in a sale is at least $78 per share."

That price is 19 percent higher than Air Products' current offer of $65.50 a share and would value Airgas at $6.5 billion.

Traders did not leap at the notion that Airgas could fetch $78 a share or more: The stock closed at $70.43, down 57 cents, on the New York Stock Exchange.

Last week, the Airgas board said it would be willing to negotiate if it thought the company would sell for "meaningfully" more than $70 a share.

Air Products said in response Friday that it was ready to negotiate immediately but did not think that "pre-conditions to any meeting are reasonable at this point."

Air Products, of Allentown, did not respond by late afternoon to today's letter from Airgas, which is based in Radnor. Both companies sell industrial and medical gases.

Airgas' appeal of a Delaware Chancery Court decision last month was scheduled Wednesday morning for oral arguments before the Delaware Supreme Court in Dover. At issue is whether Airgas' 2011 annual meeting can legally be held in January, just four months after the 2010 annual meeting.

Shareholders, led by Air Products, in September passed a bylaw change that moved the meeting to a date in the same fiscal year to speed up the potential sale of Airgas.

Contact staff writer Harold Brubaker at 215-854-4651 or hbrubaker@phillynews.com.