It begins even before I clear customs in St. Kitts, a sense that Nevis is an island apart from others in the Caribbean.
A guy with a guitar slung on his back starts chatting with people beside me in the queue, and before long, I'm in a three-way conversation, learning where to hear live music, which restaurants are closed on Mondays, and where to find trails leading to newly discovered waterfalls. (Hike up from the prison.)
In Nevis, everyone knows everyone, or so it seems, and they're happy to share news, gossip, and helpful information.
Nevis (pronounced NEE-vis), six miles wide by eight miles long, is the smaller of two sister islands, former British colonies that make up the Federation of St. Kitts and Nevis. Located in the leeward portion of the Caribbean's Lesser Antilles, both islands have lush foliage, dormant volcanoes, and uncrowded beaches, though Nevis, population 12,000, is quieter and less developed than its big sis.
Revealing Nevis as my destination to other travelers is like sharing a secret handshake in a club where those who love beach casinos, bars with DJs, and nightlife turn one way as they exit the airport, remaining in St. Kitts, while the rest of us hop into cabs to the ferry. Crossing the two-mile channel to Nevis, we arrive at a destination with one sleepy harbor town and more than 50 churches, where wild sheep and donkeys roam freely, an island reported to have more vervet monkeys than people.
"Nevis offers a distinctive sense of disconnect, which I think is so difficult to find in today's global world," said Nancy Beckham, a former Nevis resident whom I met in Miami. "No buildings are higher than a coconut palm, there aren't many vehicles, the people are educated and kind, the surroundings are lush and green, and there's plenty to explore, including wonderful historical ruins that have disappeared from other Caribbean islands."
For a recent visit, my second in five years, I lured my pal Libby down from Portland, Maine, with promises of swimming, touring, cocktailing, eating, and lounging in the sun. Call it Lollygagging 101.
Arriving at our hotel, Montpelier Plantation & Beach, Libby and I were greeted by Ziggy, a friendly, honey-colored hound dog. Javier Stanley, a bartender with an oval face and a thousand-watt smile, served us a welcoming rum punch in a tall chilled glass.
"Nevis is simple, subtle," he said. "There's not too much hustle and bustle."
"Compared to other Caribbean nations, Nevis is a step back in time," said Nikolas Mantas, the food and beverage manager. And he meant that in a good way.
Settling into island life was as easy as kicking off our shoes. After our cocktail and a dip in the pool, we took a taxi to Lime, a rustic beachside restaurant and bar with wood floors and a porch looking out at the stars. Michael Jackson rocked the sound system - "Oh baby, give me one more chance" - and we sighed over crisp tania (an island root vegetable) fritters, watermelon and feta cheese salad, and grilled grouper, sauteed onions, and pickles folded in a flour tortilla. We washed it all down with a cold Carib beer.
In the morning, wild sheep were grazing outside our room as the sun rose hot on a breezy day. The hotel was once a sugar plantation - with an old mill where you can now dine in candlelit splendor - one of several renovated plantations on this island, vestiges of an industry that dominated the economy in the 18th and early 19th centuries. Montpelier's 19 cottage rooms, with wooden beams, lazy ceiling fans, and louvered windows, are reminiscent of a time when the island was a stomping ground for well-heeled British colonists such as Lord Horatio Nelson, who married Frances Nisbet beneath a silk-cotton tree on the property.
Montpelier sits high on a mountain slope, near the often cloud-shrouded Nevis Peak (3,232 feet), and offers partial views of the distant windward shore. (The hotel offers daily shuttle service to a private beach on the leeward side.) Swimming backstroke in the pool, watching clouds skitter through the cerulean sky, I was acutely aware of being on an island afloat in a vast, pale green sea.
Slipping out of the pool and into a robe, I padded to the adjacent veranda, where Libby was sipping her morning coffee. Over a full Nevisian breakfast - farm-fresh eggs, local pork sausage, and French toast with nutmeg and island honey - we met Erin Moore and his wife, Kara Wanchick, from Jacksonville, Fla. This was their fifth visit to the island since they'd gotten married on Montpelier's beach three years earlier.
"If you come to Nevis, come with a sense of adventure," said Moore, who showed me his Nevis driver's license, a square pink card ($25).
Moore and Wanchick like to explore the island by Jeep, finding small coves and beaches each time they return. He recommended renting a car through the hotel ($50 a day) rather than directly through rental companies ($75 to $125 a day).
Neither Libby nor I felt comfortable driving "English style," on the left side of the road, so we asked the hotel to hire a driver for a day of touring. Alston Smithen, also known as "Champ," arrived in his dusty, trusty passenger van, and we set off for a leisurely circumnavigation of the island.
Champ's lilting voice provided a backdrop to our tour. We stopped at the remains of the New River Estate Sugar Mill, the last operating sugar mill on the island (closed in the 1950s), where sunlight filtered through vines partially covering a crumbling chimney and the rusting gears of steam-driven cane crushers.
At Nisbet Plantation Beach Club, another former sugar plantation turned inn, patrons in a shaded beachside bar sipped frozen rum cocktails and nibbled quesadillas with a side of plantains. "The lady married to Admiral Nelson came from this plantation," Champ said.
High on a bluff overlooking St. Kitts, St. Thomas' Lowland Church, circa 1643, is the oldest church on the island, and supposedly the oldest Anglican church in the Caribbean.
Thirsty, I requested a detour to Mansa's Last Stop, a roadside store stocked with staple groceries, beer, produce grown on a small organic farm, and homemade seasonal juices such as carambola, sorrel, passion fruit, and cucumber. Out in the extensive growing fields behind the shop, we found Mervin "Mansa" Tyson, a reed-thin man with Rasta dreads and a big smile, who offered us a tomato, warm and sweet off the vine.
A low-key, laid-back approach to tourism is what I appreciate about the island, so it was a surprise to learn that Nevis was home to the first resort for Europeans in the Caribbean. The therapeutic hot springs at the Bath Hotel, built in 1778, attracted such noteworthy visitors as Samuel Taylor Coleridge and Prince William Henry, the Duke of Clarence. The hotel is closed now, but you can still dip into its hot springs in a small outdoor pool.
We made a pit stop for sunscreen in the capital city of Charlestown. With perhaps the sleepiest town center I've ever encountered, Charlestown is home to the ferry terminal to St. Kitts, the tourism office, a sports store, a sports bar, government offices, Chinese restaurants (the island version of fast food), small souvenir shops, a pharmacy, banks and, on certain days, a market selling spices, fruit, and produce.
A visit to Nevis isn't complete without sampling a Killer Bee rum punch at Sunshine's Beach Bar & Grill. Sunshine himself served us conch fritters with his special hot sauce on the side. We hid from the heat of the day under jaunty saffron-hued umbrellas, watching kayakers paddle past as the house monkey chugged a beer. ("Come take a photo with the monkey 5 U$," read the sign on the cage.) Reggae music played, palm trees swayed, the warm turquoise sea beckoned, and life was pretty much perfect.
"You realize this is a complete fantasy," I said to Libby.
"Yes," she answered. "That's why we travel. Real life is tedious enough."