Skip to content

DeCoatsworth's girlfriend testifies in assault trial

The longtime girlfriend of former Philadelphia Police Officer Richard DeCoatsworth was described by the defense Thursday as an obsessed, scheming liar - anything but the victim of a domestic assault by the onetime hero cop.

The longtime girlfriend of former Philadelphia Police Officer Richard DeCoatsworth was described by the defense Thursday as an obsessed, scheming liar - anything but the victim of a domestic assault by the onetime hero cop.

Sadie Martinez, 29, who pressed assault charges against DeCoatsworth after a May 9, 2013, incident in his Port Richmond home, found herself on the defense as she tried to explain their volatile relationship. They had been a couple 15 years, and had lived together for seven of those.

Martinez told the Common Pleas Court jury of seven women and five men that they had been fighting early that morning about several things, including his missing car keys and his dalliances with other women. The argument ended when she tried to leave, but DeCoatsworth caught up to her, choked her, and punched her in the mouth.

But when questioned by defense attorney L. George Parry, Martinez acknowledged that she visited DeCoatsworth in prison, wrote him 39 love letters, and lived with his mother.

"You stated you were done with Richie in early May of 2013?" Parry asked.

"I didn't want to give up on him," Martinez said. "I was showing him support, and I was trying to get a better sense of what was going on."

DeCoatsworth, she said, told her he "wanted to work things out and we'd get through this."

Assistant District Attorney James Stinsman ended the prosecution case in the trial's second day.

The defense case continues Friday with DeCoatsworth, 28, deciding whether he will testify.

Judge Charles Ehrlich told the jury to expect to begin deliberating Friday.

Stinsman acknowledged discrepancies in Martinez's story, including the lies she admitted during his preliminary hearing, and swearing to a judge that the assault never happened so she could withdraw her protection-from-abuse order against DeCoatsworth.

Instead, Stinsman called a series of police witnesses to buttress Martinez's assault claim. The officers who responded to DeCoatsworth's home testified that Martinez had red marks on her neck and a swollen, bloody lower lip, and was distraught, shaking, and afraid.

Parry has argued that Martinez was accidentally injured while DeCoatsworth tried to get by her to leave. He said Martinez's lip was bloodied when DeCoatsworth tried to stop her from slamming his Corvette with a brick.

Questioning Martinez, Parry suggested she filed criminal charges against the former officer because she was angry that he had been cheating on her.

Parry argued that Martinez was obsessed with his client, who never responded to any of her letters or called her from prison.

Martinez said she and DeCoatsworth spoke regularly after his arrest when he called his mother from prison.

"We would pass the phone around," Martinez, who lived for a while with DeCoatsworth's mother, testified.

But DeCoatsworth's mother, Evelyn DeCoatsworth Myers, testified that her son wanted nothing to do with Martinez after the incident.

She said the couple's relationship was rocky for years: "She would pursue him, and he would take her back."

A week after her son's arrest, Myers said, Martinez came to her house and apologized.

"She said that what happened got out of control and a lot of police officers pushed her to press charges," Myers added.

Myers said she felt sorry for Martinez, who had nowhere to live, and invited her to stay with her.

Martinez remained with her until the end of the year, when Myers said she learned Martinez had been arrested for stealing from her employer.

"We felt we were betrayed for what she did," Myers said. "We didn't want her to stay with us anymore."

DeCoatsworth retired on disability from the police in 2011, four years after he survived a shotgun blast to the face as a rookie. DeCoatsworth was lauded as a hero for chasing his attacker for blocks and in 2008 was invited to sit next to Michelle Obama during President Obama's first State of the Union address.

jslobodzian@phillynews.com

215-854-2985 @joeslobo