Dispute over Gettysburg building heads to court
The battle over the future of the old cyclorama building at Gettysburg National Military Park heads to federal court in Washington today.
The battle over the future of the old cyclorama building at Gettysburg National Military Park heads to federal court in Washington today.
A group of modern architecture scholars sued the National Park Service in 2006 over plans to tear down the circular building, designed by renowned American architect Richard Neutra to house the historic cyclorama painting.
Lawyers representing the Recent Past Preservation Network and other plaintiffs are seeking an injunction in U.S. District Court to stop the planned demolition. They will argue that the Park Service violated federal law when it moved to demolish the 1961 building without considering alternatives.
"The National Park Service is charged with the protection of historic resources; this should have been an automatic save," said Christine Madrid French, the group's president and an author who has written extensively on Neutra's work.
Park spokeswoman Katie Lawhon said the agency did not comment on ongoing litigation. Officials say they want to remove the building because it interferes with plans to restore Ziegler's Grove, where Union troops held off Confederate forces on the third day of the Battle of Gettysburg during the Civil War.
The cyclorama building is a rare example of Neutra's civic architecture on the East Coast, said French, who along with Neutra's son and professional partner, Dion Neutra, is also a plaintiff in the suit.
The Park Service commissioned Neutra's design as part of its "Mission 66" program that helped fund the restoration of Independence Hall and build 100 new visitors centers in parks across the country.
The Park Service, which designated the building worthy of inclusion on the National Register of Historic Places, now says it is a blight on the historic landscape of Pickett's Charge.
Preservationists contend that the cyclorama building, which was dedicated on the 99th anniversary of the Gettysburg Address, is an important monument like any of the others in the park, and they accuse the Park Service of singling it out for destruction.
The 360-degree cyclorama painting depicting Pickett's Charge was removed in 2006 for restoration before being installed in the new Gettysburg Museum and Visitor Center earlier this year.
French said if the building can't be saved on the site, the Park Service should consider moving it.
Two Gettysburg businessmen have offered to accommodate the building on their nearby properties.
Eric Uberman, owner of the American Civil War Museum, located across the street, said he was willing to put the cyclorama building in his parking lot but would rather see it remain in place.
"That building was not put there willy nilly. It was chosen to go on that site," he said. "People could see the painting of Pickett's Charge and walk out and overlook the actual battlefield."
Moving costs are estimated at $5 million.
























