Skip to content

Closed-loop systems: Innovative way to dispose of Marcellus drilling debris

LUCULLUS, Pa. - As Marcellus Shale horizontal wells get bigger, they are producing vast quantities of something other than natural gas:

LUCULLUS, Pa. - As Marcellus Shale horizontal wells get bigger, they are producing vast quantities of something other than natural gas:

Drilling debris.

As gas drillers improve their ability to capture ever greater swaths of acreage - some wells now extend laterally nearly two miles - the amount of rock that is brought to the surface in the initial digging process mounts up quickly.

According to Anadarko Petroleum Corp., which is drilling on leased land in Tiadaghton State Forest near this Lycoming County hamlet, a typical horizontal Marcellus well produces more than 1,000 tons of material, about 75 truckloads.

State regulations allow cuttings to be stored in lined pits near the well site. After the drilling is completed, the pits can then be covered in plastic and entombed beneath soil, a kind of mini-landfill.

But horizonal drilling produces so much material that it cannot be easily buried at some drilling sites. Those sites may contain several wells, each producing a thousand tons of cuttings.

Anadarko, which is drilling extensively on state forest land, decided last year to convert all its Marcellus operations into closed-loop systems, eliminating pits and collecting debris in steel containers that are carted to landfills.

It also received state permission to dig up the buried cuttings from about a dozen wells it already had drilled.

"We want to say we haven't buried anything here," said Steve Woelfel, Anadarko's drilling-operations manager in Appalachia. "It always could be a risk. It could come back to you."

As the natural gas industry has come increasingly under a microscope during the Marcellus Shale gas boom, on-site burial is also under scrutiny, although state regulators and the industry maintain the practice is environmentally sound.

The well-drilling process and the cuttings it generates are separate from the controversial practice of hydraulic fracturing, which is done after the borehole is drilled and lined with steel casing and cement.

"Fracking," which involves the high-pressure injection of water, chemicals, and sand into the well to shatter the shale, produces great quantities of toxic liquid wastes. Those wastes can be recycled or treated, but they cannot be disposed of at the well site.

Long before fracking begins, cuttings from deep shale formations brought up in the initial drilling process may contain salts, metals such as barium and strontium, and some naturally occurring radioactive material, also called NORM. The debris also can contain drilling fluids.

The Delaware River Basin Commission has drafted regulations that would ban so-called reserve pits in the environmentally sensitive Delaware watershed. The DRBC's regulations would require closed-loop drilling and off-site disposal of cuttings.

"Our main concern is that materials not left on the site don't cause a future problem," said William J. Muszynski, who heads the DRBC's water resources management branch.

The Northern Wayne Property Owners Association, which represents 1,300 owners in northeastern Pennsylvania, required the companies drilling on its land to employ closed-loop systems as an environmental precaution.

Tracy Carluccio, the deputy director of the Delaware Riverkeeper Network, an environmental-advocacy group, calls the buried cuttings "a little time bomb of pollution.

"Pennsylvania should not be allowing the burials of cuttings on-site," she said. "That's definitely a pathway of pollution."

Industry officials say concerns about drill cuttings are exaggerated. "Cuttings are basically just rocks," said Louis D'Amico, president of the Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association.

In some states, operators dispose of drilling debris by plowing it into fields, a practice known as "land-farming." Other "beneficial uses" include using cuttings on gravel roads or mixing them with asphalt as paving material.

Jamie Legenos, a spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, said the state had received no formal requests for beneficial uses of drill cuttings.

Natural gas drilling has aroused such ardent opposition that even disposing of cuttings at approved landfills has raised alarms, forcing landfill operators to assure local officials that all incoming waste is tested for radioactivity and hazardous materials.

The advent of shale-gas drilling in Pennsylvania is transforming an industry that had been dominated by smaller, shallow-well operators.

"The Marcellus has attracted a whole different scale of operations," said James Erb, a consultant to the Associated Petroleum Industries of Pennsylvania. The larger companies are importing new practices, including closed-loop drilling systems, he said.

Although several operators are using closed-loop systems, Anadarko's practices are being held up as an industry best practice.

The Marcellus Shale Coalition arranged for former Gov. Tom Ridge, its strategic adviser, to tour an Anadarko well site in Lycoming County earlier this month to learn more about closed-loop drilling.

State regulators say closed-loop systems show promise, though DEP is not considering requiring the practice statewide.

"Closed-loop drilling has potential to enable a larger scale of reuse for drilling mud and would eradicate the need for a drilling waste pit, which in turn would eliminate earth disturbance and possible erosion and sediment-control issues," said the DEP's Legenos.

Anadarko says the closed-loop system is part of a broader "no-spill" strategy aimed at keeping all materials contained during the drilling process.

Said Scott Chesebro, Anadarko's engineering manager for Appalachian operations: "Nothing we bring to the surface touches the ground."

Contact staff writer Andrew Maykuth at 215-854-2947 or amaykuth@phillynews.com.