Skip to content

Gosnells, with lawyers, go to court

Kermit Gosnell and his wife, Pearl, were all lawyered up yesterday, a week after telling a judge that they were too broke to hire attorneys to fight charges that they ran an abortion clinic where a patient died and seven viable babies were delivered, then killed.

Kermit Gosnell and his wife, Pearl, were all lawyered up yesterday, a week after telling a judge that they were too broke to hire attorneys to fight charges that they ran an abortion clinic where a patient died and seven viable babies were delivered, then killed.

Jack McMahon, the high-profile criminal-defense attorney, told Common Pleas Judge Renee Cardwell Hughes that he is representing Kermit Gosnell, 69.

Mary Therese Maran, who works at McMahon's Center City firm, is representing Pearl Gosnell, 50.

The Gosnells, who made millions over decades running their West Philadelphia Women's Medical Society clinic, own at least seven properties and should be able to afford attorneys, prosecutors argued successfully last week in convincing Hughes not to grant them public defenders.

Yesterday, Maran concurred. "The Gosnell family has significant assets," she said after the hearing.

Gosnell is "doing well. He's doing fine," McMahon said before hurrying to the courtroom next door to defend Temple Law School student Gerald Ung, on trial for attempted murder.

Hughes granted a prosecution motion yesterday to bypass preliminary hearings for the Gosnells and their eight co-defendants.

McMahon, Maran and most of the attorneys representing the eight other defendants objected to the prosecution motion to strip the defense attorneys' clients of their preliminary hearings - the step in the criminal-justice process when a judge determines if the prosecution has made its case that the accused should be held for trial.

Assistant district attorneys Joanne Pescatore and Christine Wechsler told Hughes that such a hearing is not needed in this case.

An 8-month investigation by a grand jury included interviews with 63 witnesses, including doctors, and concluded with a 260-page report outlining the charges in fine detail, Wechsler said.

Pescatore, noting that it took about 30 minutes yesterday just to find seats for all of the defendants and their attorneys, said that the cost and logistical problems would be greater if a preliminary hearing were held.

Hughes, who presided over the grand jury, agreed. "If we had a preliminary hearing, we would shut down the Criminal Justice Center for days; it's not warranted," said Hughes, noting the extra number of deputy sheriffs who were reassigned to her courtroom for yesterday's hearing.

Maran said she wanted a preliminary hearing because the grand-jury report indicates that Pearl Gosnell was "minimally involved at best, or possibly not even involved. And I think it's absolutely her right to challenge a conclusion otherwise."

McMahon said: "We thought it would be helpful in a potential death-penalty case to cross-examine some of these witnesses. But we will get the discovery now, and we can begin preparing."

Prosecutors have not determined whether to seek the death penalty against Gosnell, who is charged with murdering a patient and seven newborns. He remains jailed without bail. His wife also remains behind bars, having failed to pay 10 percent of a $1 million bail. Maran said she will soon ask Hughes for a bail reduction.