Question:

I recently found a $28-per-night rate at the Westin Imagine in Orlando. I was amazed. I booked the room, and several days later I called the hotel to ensure that it was a legitimate rate. The hotel confirmed, so I booked nonrefundable airfare, and have been happily anticipating my getaway weekend ever since.

That is, until I received an e-mail from the hotel's director of revenue management saying the rate was caused by a "keystroke error" during data entry. The actual rate was $289. The Westin offered a rate of $99 per night as an apology, but refused to honor the original rate.

I contacted Westin at the corporate level, and the hotel offered to waive its mandatory valet parking charge of $18 per night, but insisted it couldn't honor the $28 rate. Then the manager of the hotel responded, offering to throw in an extra 5,000 loyalty points.

I'm writing because I don't think I'm getting fair treatment by this Westin hotel. If there is anything you can do to help, I would be extremely appreciative. - T.C., San Diego
Answer: When you book a rate that you know is an error, you shouldn't expect the hotel to honor the price. But $28 per night wasn't an obvious "fat finger" rate, and the fact that Westin confirmed it certainly didn't help.

If the hotel had offered rooms at $0, this would be a different story. Actually, it wouldn't be a story at all. When a business mistakenly prices something at a rate no reasonable customer believes is valid, it shouldn't be required to honor that price. But you can find hotel rooms at $28 a night.

I admit, it's not a popular opinion. You don't have to look hard to find one of those vintage online forums where people feel that a travel company must honor every rate, no matter how ridiculously low. Nor do you have to search long to find a travel columnist who supports this misguided view.

They have a right to their opinion, but I won't advocate for them. People who try to force travel companies to accept unreasonable or erroneous prices are stealing - no two ways about it.

You pushed the Westin to do the right thing. But did you push too hard? Your first contact resulted in a $190-per-night rate reduction. Not bad. Subsequent requests prompted the hotel to remove its "mandatory valet parking charge" and throw in a few extra frequent-stayer points. (I could write a whole column about mandatory valet parking charges, but I'll restrain myself.)

Is that enough?

That seems pretty generous to me, but I thought I would give the hotel one more chance to review your case. I asked the general manager to consider your request, and although he wouldn't lower your room rate, he agreed to pay for your airfare to Orlando.

I think that's a more-than-equitable resolution.

Christopher Elliott is the ombudsman for National Geographic Traveler magazine. E-mail him at celliott@ngs.org or troubleshoot your trip through his Web site, www.elliott.org.