Skip to content

State share of tobacco settlement shrinks by $180M

HARRISBURG The state has frozen $100 million slated for health research, prescription drugs, and smoking-cessation programs because an arbitration panel slashed its share of the 1998 tobacco settlement that had been paying for the programs.

In a ruling last month, the panel overseeing a multistate settlement found that Pennsylvania had failed to adequately enforce certain terms of the agreement with tobacco manufacturers.
In a ruling last month, the panel overseeing a multistate settlement found that Pennsylvania had failed to adequately enforce certain terms of the agreement with tobacco manufacturers.Read more

HARRISBURG The state has frozen $100 million slated for health research, prescription drugs, and smoking-cessation programs because an arbitration panel slashed its share of the 1998 tobacco settlement that had been paying for the programs.

In a ruling last month, the panel overseeing the multistate settlement found that Pennsylvania had failed to adequately enforce certain terms of the agreement with tobacco manufacturers.

The arbitrators said the companies could cut their annual payments to the commonwealth by $180 million - or about 60 percent of the nearly $320 million the state had been getting every year.

"We are deeply disappointed by the recent decision of the master settlement agreement [MSA] arbitration panel," Budget Secretary Charles Zogby said Wednesday. "MSA payments fund important health-related programs across the state."

As a result, Zogby said, funding has been frozen for health research, prescription drugs for low-income elderly residents, uncompensated care, and smoking cessation programs. Funding dedicated to long-term care and services for the disabled will not be reduced.

Zogby said the decision only affects 2014 payments and that the money could be restored in later years.

Attorney General Kathleen Kane last week filed a motion asking the arbitration panel to reconsider the ruling.

The ruling was released on Sept. 11 but the state held off announcing it until this week because officials wanted to measure the impact, said Gov. Corbett's spokesman, Jay Pagni.

Under the 1998 settlement with four of the largest tobacco manufacturers, 46 states and the District of Columbia were to receive an estimated $206 billion over 25 years.

Like other states, Pennsylvania gets payments based on tobacco sales - an annual payout around $300 million. Unlike other states, however, legislation here mandated that the funds be used exclusively for health care.

The panel ruled on settlement payment disputes involving 15 states. Nine won favorable decisions over the money, while the panel found six - including Pennsylvania - failed to properly enforce escrow settlement provisions involving "nonparticipating manufacturers."

The tobacco companies claimed Pennsylvania in 2003 failed to properly tax loose-leaf tobacco used in "roll your own" cigarettes.

In appealing the ruling, Kane said the companies miscalculated the percentage of sales of roll-your-own tobacco, which it said represents just a fraction of the overall tobacco market.

Kane's chief of staff, Adrian King, said the attorney general would seek all avenues to restore the payments.

"We are not going to sit on our hands," King said in an interview. "We are going to proceed with any and all remedies in state and federal court."

717-783-2584

@inkyamy