Cigarette tax the best we can do?
The initial backslapping over the then-expected passage of the cigarette tax to help bail out Philadelphia schools is similar to the accolades for the performance of the U.S. soccer team in the World Cup. As you might recall, everyone was going gaga over the U.S. performance, though the team won only one game, lost two, and tied one.

The initial backslapping over the then-expected passage of the cigarette tax to help bail out Philadelphia schools is similar to the accolades for the performance of the U.S. soccer team in the World Cup. As you might recall, everyone was going gaga over the U.S. performance, though the team won only one game, lost two, and tied one.
The reason for all the backslapping - both by soccer fans and supporters of another sin tax to support the basic right of education - is that we set our expectations so low.
Success with soccer was moving on to one more round, not winning the World Cup or even getting into the semis or finals. Legislative success for funding the School District was fending off more layoffs, not enhancing high-quality education. No wonder the district hobbles along in perpetual bankruptcy - financially and educationally in terms of expectations and aspirations.
The chase for a cigarette tax serves as an invaluable lesson. It represents the Band-Aid theory of leadership. Define a crisis, toss up some solutions, then debate, bicker, and hit a stalemate. Watch as they wring their hands as the deadline approaches. Then, at the very last minute, the political magicians pull a rabbit out of the hat and everyone breathes a sigh of relief, congratulates one another, and goes home for the holidays.
But as dusk turns into daylight, we realize the rabbit was illusory; at best, it was a Band-Aid. The hemorrhaging will continue with or without the tax.
Is this the best our elected officials can do for our schoolchildren? Come up with another sin tax - first liquor by the drink, then cigarettes? What happened to the rhetoric about how important education is to our children, the vitality of the city, the growth of the commonwealth?
In a city where so many political leaders talk about income inequality or education as our next civil rights issue, I can't fathom why they don't take on some tougher hombres than cigarette smokers.
Imagine if those brave civil rights fighters of the 1960s were willing to fight only pussycats, rather than Bull Connor's sharp-fanged dogs.
The real sin is not drinking or smoking; it's not having the gumption to take on the big boys.
Let's start with developers. The city's 10-year tax abatement on construction belongs to a no-growth era. Times have changed; it's time to scale it back and stop robbing the schools of these property-tax revenues.
Another example is our corporatized Meds and Eds - hospitals and universities - which refuse to provide any money to our schools, continuing to hide behind the mask of being nonprofits.
These targets are just examples. Most important, the methodology for funding public education needs to be changed. And if you aren't convinced that's true, take a walk through Lower Merion High School and then take a one-mile ride to Overbrook High School, just across the city line. After you've seen both, look in the mirror and see if you can tell yourself that our current system of funding education is fair.
For now, though, as long as we set the bar so low, there is no reason for legislators to do anything but perform more magic tricks. And as the last-minute dickering over the cigarette tax proves, it takes as much energy to get little things passed as it does for meaningful reforms. If you have to work just as hard, why not set the bar higher?
That higher standard begins with the School Reform Commission. The SRC was created more than a decade ago for two reasons: Improve educational attainment, and ensure that the district's fiscal house was in order and tax money spent wisely.
There has been significant emphasis and improvement with the second priority, particularly under Superintendent William R. Hite Jr. But the improvement of education is getting lost in the green-eye-shade mentality.
Hite had the right idea when he put a price tag on how much is needed to improve educational output rather than just limping along. Unfortunately, the SRC didn't include those expenses in the district's budget. Instead it sought just enough money to open the doors and prevent more layoffs.
The budget needs to represent the true costs of providing a meaningful education. Not a pipe-dream sum, just the amount that would equalize the opportunity that the surrounding districts have.
And then tell the powers that be that schools will open in September and will remain open for as long as the district has the funds. Let the burden be on the politicians to close the schools for lack of funding.
Some will say this is the "train wreck" strategy that former Superintendent David Hornbeck threatened to implement in the 1990s. Then we had to imagine how bad things could be without adequate funding or if the state took control. Now the state is in charge, and the train wreck is here. What else would you call a school system with an inadequate number of nurses and guidance counselors, with run-down facilities, with donations needed for basic supplies?
I prefer to call it the Robert Browning strategy, named for the poet who wrote, "A man's reach should exceed his grasp, Or what's a heaven for?" In this case, may our politicians' reach exceed their bankrupt pragmatism, or what's a school district for?
























