By Brian Hickey
There are 19 reasons to set aside the hysteria over last week's erroneous reports that Philadelphia plans to punish people for texting while walking. Police should be on the lookout for - and even issue fines to - egregiously distracted pedestrians.
The city's continuing "Give Respect - Get Respect" campaign to reduce distraction, which generated the exaggerated stories, is not unprecedented. A yearlong 1997 initiative called "Operation Crosswalk" also increased traffic enforcement and education. It was different in that it targeted drivers, while today's effort encompasses bicyclists and pedestrians, too. But the aim was similar.
One benefit of the prior campaign: a 56 percent increase in citations for offenses such as failing to yield the right of way to pedestrians and running stop signs. Another benefit: Officers paid a little attention to jaywalkers, issuing 13 tickets for the offense, compared with two the year before. "They went after the nitwits - you know, the guy who dances out [into traffic] and then gives the driver the finger," a police spokesman said.
Crosswalk's greatest contribution was that the number of pedestrians killed that year fell to 41 - down from 60 the year before, and fewer than in any of the previous 10 years.
Let's put that into perspective: Nineteen more people were alive in 1998, and the city's effort to educate drivers may have been partly responsible for that.
The latest city data show that more than 1,800 pedestrians and more than 435 cyclists were struck by vehicles last year. So this problem hasn't disappeared.
A day after last week's story went viral with her name attached, Rina Cutler, the deputy mayor for transportation and utilities, offered some other compelling statistics: "Over the past five years, about 30 pedestrians and three bicyclists are killed each year by cars in Philly. That is almost one pedestrian killed every 11 days."
It's often the fault of drivers, but not always. So far, some 600 bicyclists (along with 100 motorists) have been warned about dangerous behavior under the current campaign. Meanwhile, police issued 205 tickets for jaywalking and other pedestrian offenses in the first half of this year, up from 142 during the same period last year.
But the city took pains to quiet the hubbub over a supposed pedestrian crackdown last week. Mayor Nutter himself texted: "It is NOT illegal to text and walk in Philly. You will NOT be fined. You will NOT be ticketed." And Cutler and Police Commissioner Charles H. Ramsey issued a statement saying, "Pedestrians may be reminded to be more aware of their surroundings; however, there are no citations issued by the [police] for texting while walking. If a Philadelphia police officer observes a driver, cyclist, or pedestrian participating in any kind of potentially dangerous behavior, the officer will remind them to be careful."
And, within a block, they will have forgotten all about that friendly reminder.
At a time when even Justin Bieber is participating in a campaign against texting while driving, why are city officials so eager to extend immunity to the nitwits who absentmindedly amble into traffic or focus on typing "LOL" into their smartphones instead of looking both ways?
The snarky international attention - even though it was based on bad information - likely had something to do with it, especially since it hasn't been very long since the whole kerfuffle (also overblown) about a city "blogger tax."
When I suggested to Cutler that police should indeed fine egregiously distracted pedestrians, she said, "I might agree in principle, but think it would be mostly unenforceable."
But try standing at 15th and Market with a notebook and counting the number of distracted walkers traipsing into traffic. You'll need more paper after an hour.
Officers are handing out pamphlets advising pedestrians to "Be Responsible and Courteous," "Use Crosswalks - Save Your Life," and keep their "Eyes on the Road." Clearly, they could issue some tickets along with them.
"As long as we all share the roadway, we will need to look out for each other," Cutler told me. "A little courtesy and respect will go a long way.
"This really is a safety issue. I am less worried about traffic disruption than I am about pedestrian injuries and death."
I, too, worry about pedestrian injuries and death, which is why the city should heed the lessons of 14 years ago. I'm not saying fine everybody; I'm saying fine those risking injury not only to themselves, but to others.
People probably mocked Operation Crosswalk, too. But it may have saved the life of somebody you know or share a crosswalk with in Center City.
























