Coachella 'Old Guys' fest: Why this old guy won't go
Out in Indio, Calif., in the middle of the Coachella Valley, they'll put on a festival Oct. 7-9 that - if it were 1975 - would be one of the greatest lineups in the history of pop music: the Rolling Stones and Bob Dylan (Oct. 7), Paul McCartney and Neil Young (Oct. 8), and Roger Waters (once of Pink Floyd) and The Who (Oct. 9).

Out in Indio, Calif., in the middle of the Coachella Valley, they'll put on a festival Oct. 7-9 that - if it were 1975 - would be one of the greatest lineups in the history of pop music: the Rolling Stones and Bob Dylan (Oct. 7), Paul McCartney and Neil Young (Oct. 8), and Roger Waters (once of Pink Floyd) and The Who (Oct. 9).
And I am not going. And I would not go.
It's not that it won't be fun. The audience will know all the songs. May they dance all weekend. May they get the cosmic feel-goods all over. They should: If there ever were a deep set list, this is it.
It's not that the boys can't play anymore. Stay in practice, and you can stave off the collapse of your musical skills. Neil can still deafen you with "Cinnamon Girl," and Roger will slay on "Another Brick in the Wall, Part 2." All these boys offer excellent musical acts that will rock and then also roll.
The voices, well, all of them, even the apparently indestructible McCartney's, are getting grainy and ragged, and at least two of them (Dylan and Young) always were. But they will get the job done.
If you're going to Desert Trip, as this is officially called, or the Old Guys Festival, as this is unofficially called, I hope and believe you will have a great time.
But I am not going. And I would not go. Here's why.
It's all about me, so shut up. These guys are very old, and they remind me I am very old, and I don't like that. It embarrasses me to watch old guys rock. (As an old musician, I embarrass myself.) Who really loves seeing thickened 70-year-old guys who wear their hair, if they have any, as they did in 1969?
But it's more than that. I am in no mood to be reminded of the state I'm in and the state toward which I'm headed.
If I went, I would remember the rockin' departed, my hero John Entwistle and his bandmate Keith Moon of The Who (now called The Two, because that's all that's left). I would remember John Lennon and George Harrison and Brian Jones and Syd Barrett and Richard Wright. And all the living who are not there - Dave Gilmour or Ringo Starr, or Bill Wyman, or Crosby, Stills, and Nash. (Will a few of them show up?)
Those playing, they're all great, and they deserve their stardom, but none of them is cheating the Reaper - they're sprinting into his arms. As are we all. And I don't have to be reminded. And I will be if I go. So I will not go.
Let's play Soak the Geezers! Even more lamentable is this industry of Geezer Rock, the tours, the festivals, tapping the life savings of m-m-m-my generation, squeezing us dry turnips for every cent of nostalgic cash to see the bands we loved when we were young. Boomerfests ride the wave of the festival movement worldwide. And these cable channels on weekends, playing nothing but CD-compilation offers of Herman's Hermits, Now That's Country!, Guitar Rock, Girl Bands, Metal Mania! It's enough to turn you into an old person. Which I am.
(One thing I will not discuss because, come on, you know: This entire thing is White Man Babylon. It's not McCartney's fault or Bob's or Neil's. They just play. But, hey, Old Guys promoters, no Stevie? Really? No Smokey? No Gladys? No Tina? No Carlos? Wouldn't have killed you.)
Desert Trip/Old Guys = Soak the Geezers Deluxe. The ticket prices make me want to go lie down. General admission for the weekend is $399; a single-day pass is $199. You'd almost plunk it down, except that's very general admission, as in, "in the same county." Decent tickets? Floor tix are $699, $999, and $1,599; grandstands are $999 and $1,599; pits and stage-front tix are $1,599. Plus, you have to camp, which is $950 plus fees for RVs ($1,600 deluxe) or $99 for a tent. And then the food: $225 for Outstanding in the Field, the culinary festival.
Too much. I am not going. And I would not go.
The awful tooth. Perhaps like me, you are not going because festivals like Old Guys, although they proclaim that the music still lives, equally proclaim that rock is dead. Rock always has been. "Rock is dead, they say. Long live rock," sang The Who in the early 1970s. Rock was dead back then. And it still is. It is a music of the young, the denied, the misunderstood, a music of lust, fun, frustration, and aimless ambition. It is music with a chip on its shoulder, music with something to prove. It has to stay dead to stay fresh.
Which is why I could never go to Old Guys.
See, more than a bunch of times after a gig, I will be approached by a musician a third or less my age, and s/he will ask: "How come you guys got all the good music? Why is so much of it so great? Where does all that electricity come from?" It feels good to hear them because, deep in my egalitarian heart, I think the same thing.
By the same token, listen around. Rock is hardly the music of the moment. This moment, 2016 and forward, deserves its own music. All these younger musicians grew up listening to the music of my moment, but they dance and make love to Kanye and Katy and Kendrick and Taylor and . . . Old Guys will just remind me of that, too.
What to do instead? Listen to new music. Sure, all Oct. 7-9 weekend long, many of us may be pretending we are at Old Guys, tracking "Old Man" and "When I'm Sixty-Four" and "Won't Get Fooled Again" and "Blowin' in the Wind."
But between each, listen to some new music, and then keep listening until you are dead. This is my plan.
Research suggests we stop listening to new music somewhere in our 40s and dwell thenceforth with the sonic ghosts of our primes. I totally get that. I love all the great stuff of the 1960s and 1970s. I listen all the time. But good music happens all the time, too. Listen to some. You're not turning away from your Paul/Mick/Bob/Neil/Pete/Roger, your Beach Boys, Grass Roots, O'Jays, Tammy Wynette, 1910 Fruitgum Company, Vanilla Fudge, Kinks, and Cecilio & Kapono. Your artists will always have a deep, visceral meaning, worked forever into the roots of your being, your memories, your coming-up, your coming-of-age. They always will be with you.
In listening to new music, once in a while, you are just adding to them. And to yourself.
I (and maybe you?) saw McCartney on his 1976 Wings Over America tour. I saw The Who, all four, at the Charlton Rock Festival in 1974 and again elsewhere. I saw Young with CSN in L.A. in a wild 1970 concert, and I saw Dylan at a charmed 2006 show at the Spectrum. All were terrific. So I have that. I'll save my $3,500, try to forget how floppy, rutted, wrinkled, and run-over I am getting - and, after listening to some old music and some new, go out and kick the leaves, reveling in one of my lessening number of remaining autumns.
215-854-4406@jtimpane
























