Skip to content

Philly TV news battle heats up between 6abc and NBC10, boosted by NBC Sports Philadelphia

"Action News" remains dominant in Philadelphia, but "NBC10 News" is presenting a serious challenge for the first time in years.

NBC10 anchors Keith Jones and Erin Coleman at the station's studios in the Comcast Technology Center in Philadelphia.
NBC10 anchors Keith Jones and Erin Coleman at the station's studios in the Comcast Technology Center in Philadelphia.Read moreAlejandro A. Alvarez / Staff Pho / Alejandro A. Alvarez / Staff Pho

Today’s big story: NBC10 is posing the first serious ratings challenge to 6abc in years.

Even without household names like Cecily Tynan and Jim Gardner, Action News remains the most-watched local newscast in Philadelphia and across the Delaware Valley.

But from August through October, NBC10 drew more news viewers than 6abc among adults between the ages of 25 and 54 — a key advertiser demographic — during their 6 a.m. and 11 p.m. newscasts, according to Nielsen data.

It’s the first three-month win streak for NBC10 since at least 2010. 11 p.m. anchors Jacqueline London and Fred Shropshire have topped Rick Williams at 6abc in that demographic in seven of the past 13 months, according to NBC10 President and General Manager Joel Davis.

6abc declined to comment.

NBC10’s 6 a.m. newscast, featuring Keith Jones and Erin Coleman, has seen its audience in the 25-to-54 demographic grow by more than 60% compared to last year, even though NBC’s Today show trails both ABC’s Good Morning America and Fox 29’s Good Day Philadelphia in the market and morning viewers tend to be more loyal to their chosen station.

6abc drew more viewers on every other newscast, including the 6 p.m. edition of Action News, which has nearly double the audience of its NBC10 counterpart in the 25-54 demographic. 6abc still draws more local news viewers overall than NBC10 and has three of Philadelphia’s most-watched shows — Jeopardy!, Wheel of Fortune, and ABC World News Tonight with David Muir.

Still, it’s a sign of progress under Davis, a local news veteran who has been running NBC’s three Philly networks — NBC10, Telemundo62, and NBC Sports Philadelphia — since last year.

“Three months of success is good, but it’s going to take time,” Davis said. “We expect there will be back and forth over the next several months.”

So how has NBC10 won over viewers? Davis said getting the right personalities in the correct time slots is part of it, but he credited the station’s decision to bump up weekday local news to eight hours a day.

Gone are daytime soap operas and syndicated shows. Outside of prime time, the station looks and feels more like a 24-hour news channel, adding 2 p.m. and 7:30 p.m. newscasts. NBC’s commitment to live sports in prime time certainly hasn’t hurt.

“Everything that succeeds in this day and age in television is live and local to some degree, whether it be news or sports,” Davis said.

NBC Sports Philadelphia is boosting NBC10’s growth, but questions linger

Davis cited another reason for NBC10’s recent ratings success: leveraging NBC’s local sports TV rights, which include broadcasting Phillies, 76ers, and Flyers games.

Last summer, Davis asked for a list of the 100 most-viewed programs in the Philly TV market that year. About 70% were sports broadcasts on NBC Sports Philadelphia, largely dominated by Phillies games.

Thanks to the addition of LeBron James, Sixers games are drawing nearly 215,000 viewers per game on NBC Sports Philadelphia this season through Wednesday, up 150% compared to last season’s average, according to Nielsen numbers.

The interest extends to the station’s studio programming. Sixers Pregame Live is up more than 220% over last season, averaging over 50,000 viewers. Sixers Postgame Live is averaging nearly 80,000 viewers.

Before Davis took over, there was very little cross-promotion between the three stations. Now viewers regularly see NBC Sports Philadelphia personalities like Amy Fadool Kane on NBC10 promoting and discussing games and vice versa.

“When we run news promos in NBC Sports Philadelphia, we are getting a younger audience exposed to our news product,” Davis said.

Despite its success, a lot of uncertainty hangs over NBC Sports Philadelphia’s future.

Cord cutting has been tough on regional sports networks across the country, and NBC is down from nine of these such networks in 2012 to just four — Philly, Boston, San Francisco, and Northern California. NBC is also in the midst of massive change as parent company Comcast spins off NBCUniversal into a separate company, a move scheduled to be completed next year.

Add to that uncertainty plans by the NBA and MLB to launch their own in-market streaming service to offer local games, which could drive more fans to cut their cable subscriptions. Currently, fans in the Philly TV market can stream Phillies, Sixers, and Flyers games without a cable subscription using Peacock.

There have been rumblings NBC is looking to divest from its remaining regional sports networks as cord cutting continues, but in Philly any sale would be complicated by the fact the Phillies own 25% of the network as part of a 25-year, $2.5 billion deal that runs through 2041.

“While the deals may adjust over time as the industry changes,” Davis said, “I think there’s a firm understanding here that there’s great value in this particular market that it makes total sense to have this partnership in place.”