Mother urges Philly death-penalty jury to spare her son's life
It is a past many a woman would struggle to hide: sexual molestation and beatings by her stepfather from age 8 to 15, when she fled her Lower Bucks County home to live on the streets of New Orleans.
It is a past many a woman would struggle to hide: sexual molestation and beatings by her stepfather from age 8 to 15, when she fled her Lower Bucks County home to live on the streets of New Orleans.
She abused alcohol and a myriad of illegal drugs; worked as a prostitute in Atlantic City; married a long-haul trucker she met hitchhiking; bore six children, one stillborn and another who drowned at 14 months; was repeatedly committed to mental hospitals; and was exorcised by a Memphis congregation to cast out her demons.
Shirley Drummond shared it all Wednesday for a Common Pleas Court jury in an attempt to engender enough sympathy that 12 jurors would send her son Gerald to prison for life and not the death chamber.
In December, the jury found Gerald Drummond, 26, and Robert McDowell, 28, both of Tacony, guilty of first-degree murder in the racially tinged killings of Damien Holloway, 27, and Timmy Clark, 15, on July 13, 2007.
After a two-week break for the holidays, the jury began hearing evidence in the penalty phase on Tuesday. Testimony is expected through Friday before deliberations begin.
At trial, prosecution witnesses said Drummond had a grudge against Holloway because of race - Drummond and McDowell are white; Holloway was black - and because Holloway was separated from Drummond's sister, with whom he had a severely disabled child.
The pair spotted Holloway and Clark about 2:20 a.m. as they walked in the 6900 block of Vandike Street toward Clark's home from a convenience store.
Clark, who was white, worked in Holloway's lawn-cutting business, and Holloway was living with Clark's family.
The prosecution said Drummond ordered Holloway and Clark to kneel, hands behind their heads, and told McDowell to shoot them. McDowell balked. Drummond grabbed the revolver and shot each in the head.
No gun was found, and no blood or DNA linked Drummond or McDowell to the killings. The prosecution relied on friends and associates who said both had described the shootings in detail.
The hearing began with Assistant District Attorney Carlos Vega presenting victim-impact testimony by Bette Clark, Timmy's mother.
Vega ended his case Wednesday with emotional testimony from Holloway's older sister, Denille, 32.
She told how she raised Damien, two other brothers, and a sister after their father left and their mother became too ill to care for them.
"I feel like a failure," Holloway said of her brother's murder. "The only thing my mother asked me to do was to take care of her special child [Damien], and that was the one thing I didn't do."
The hearing then moved to the defense, with Drummond's attorney, William L. Bowe, asking Shirley Drummond to explain how her boy became the man he is.
Drummond, 50, now sober and a "minister of the Gospel," frequently wept as she described her life and the childhoods of her children.
Gerald Drummond and his brother David, 29, who sat in the gallery, also wept - especially when their mother described the drowning of their 14-month-old brother, Johnny.
The family was living on an Arkansas farm. She recalled hanging laundry while the three boys and their sister, Andrea, played outside. Gerald, then 2, started pointing toward an irrigation well pond, Shirley Drummond said.
"He had watched his brother drown," she said tearfully. "They all did."
Nor did life improve after she and her husband divorced, and she returned with her children to Philadelphia. By then, she said, she was heavily using crack cocaine.
Only later, she said, did she learn that friends had begun feeding Gerald drugs at age 6 at her parties, and that they later groomed the boy to carry drugs for them.
























