Skip to content

Letters: Debunking Bunch's story on fracking

WILL BUNCH'S recent commentary "Pa. Fracking Boom Goes Bust" would be newsworthy - if it were actually true. His anti-gas views and perpetuation of America's reliance on foreign energy is a disservice to your readers.

WILL BUNCH'S recent commentary "Pa. Fracking Boom Goes Bust" would be newsworthy - if it were actually true. His anti-gas views and perpetuation of America's reliance on foreign energy is a disservice to your readers.

"Bust"? Tell that to the nearly 245,000 Pennsylvanians who go to work every day in the oil-and- gas industry. This industry, and its employees, have contributed more than $1.6 billion to the state's coffers - money for education, health care and other critical needs. An additional $400 million in impact fees is ensuring that communities have the resources they need to deal with shale impacts, while expanding funding for Growing Greener watershed protection, conservation districts, parks, water and sewer projects, and other environmental programs.

In addition, all Pennsylvanians are benefiting from lower energy prices. Natural-gas customers in Philadelphia alone have seen their costs decline by nearly 55 percent in the last five years; electricity prices are down nearly 40 percent. This abundant production - which has vaulted Pennsylvania from 10th to second in the nation in gas production - has saved Pennsylvania residents and businesses an estimated $10 billion - and increased the competitiveness of our suppliers and manufacturers.

Bunch fails to realize that shale-gas development occurs in phases. More than 7,000 wells have been drilled-but almost 3,000 of these are waiting for pipeline capacity to catch up. Nationwide, a higher percentage of gas rigs are in Pennsylvania than two years ago. Construction of new pipeline - rejuvenating companies such as US Steel - may not be as recognizable as building a drill rig, but at $1.5 million spent per mile, it creates just as much economic impact.

These pipelines - and the national shift to drilling for domestic oil - are having their own positive economic impact. Just ask the 3,000 direct and more than 20,000 indirect employees who still have jobs thanks to the bipartisan effort that Gov. Corbett spearheaded to save the Trainer and South Philadelphia refineries. Or, consider the wet-gas production in southwestern Pennsylvania that is breathing new life into the Marcus Hook refinery.

Here's something else that Bunch fails to tell your readers: How Gov. Corbett led the effort to enact tough environmental standards widely viewed as among the best in the nation. Working in a bipartisan manner with the General Assembly, Gov. Corbett signed legislation increasing penalties for environmental violations, requiring online disclosure of frack chemicals, expanding safety oversight of pipelines, increasing protections for streams, water wells and public water supplies, and a host of other far-reaching environmental protection enhancements.

In 2011, with the world watching, Gov. Corbett boldly laid out his plan to protect Pennsylvania's environment while growing our economy. His plan is working.

That's the story worth telling.

Patrick Henderson

Energy Executive

Office of Gov. Tom Corbett

Will Bunch's story fundamentally fails to provide your readers with critical facts about safe shale development.

Despite the unfounded claims advanced in the story, this week, in announcing approval for a liquefied natural-gas export project in southern Maryland, the U.S. Department of Energy underscored this fact: "The development of U.S. natural-gas resources is having a transformative impact on the U.S. energy landscape, helping to improve our energy security while spurring economic development and job creation around the country."

Mr. Bunch's claim that "a flood of out-of-state workers" make up the shale workforce in Pennsylvania also doesn't align with the facts. To be sure, more than 96 percent of new hires into our region's shale industry are from Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Ohio, Maryland and New York - all states in the Appalachian Basin. And nationally, oil and gas job creation continues to outpace other sectors.

While drilling activities have indeed slowed, natural-gas production levels in Pennsylvania continue to soar - another important fact omitted by Mr. Bunch. And during the first six months of this year, natural gas production spiked a staggering 58 percent year-over-year, leading to more affordable energy - and cleaner air - for consumers and businesses across the region, especially in Philadelphia. This fact was highlighted in a recent IHS study, which determined that shale development has boosted average U.S. household incomes by $1,200 last year.

The facts are clear: safe, job-creating shale development is having a positive economic, environmental and national-security impact and will continue to for generations to come. Mr. Bunch's baseless claims are "all hat and no cattle."

Shari Williams

Marcellus Shale Coalition

Philadelphia