Skip to content

DN Editorial: District distraction

A special district for failing schools won’t help, funding will

AMONG THE MANY things lost on the Harrisburg General Assembly - a strong work ethic, for example - count irony among the biggest.

Case in point: As a lawsuit makes its way through the courts that claims the state fails to uphold its constitutional obligation to educate children adequately because of an "irrational funding policy," one lawmaker, Sen. Lloyd Smucker, R.-Lancaster, wants to give the state's failing schools a few years to turn around; if they don't, they get put in a special state-run district.

As an incentive to failing schools, maybe it could work: After all, there are few scarier things on earth than the notion of being relegated to a "special state-run school district."

The lack of connection between the state's inability to fund the schools more equitably and the result - failing schools - is troubling.

Sen. Smucker is still working out the details about how such a special district would actually operate, or why such oversight would lead to better results. He envisions a seven-member board overseeing the district, with an executive who acts as superintendent. Failing schools trying to turn around would be granted more flexibility in their ability to hire outside contractors and have exemption from some union rules. The plan does not call for increased funding for such schools.

It's hard to understand why state intervention would make a difference, especially given that the majority of failing schools are in Philadelphia, which has been overseen by the state since 2001.

The heart of the problem is not governance, but resources. That's why the lawsuit against the state, which is expected to go before the state Supreme Court, could make more of a difference in failing schools than a new governance structure. The law says that the state must provide a "thorough and efficient education."

In the past, the courts have said that funding schools is the purview of the Legislature. But this time around, the court may be more receptive to weighing in on this, since what constitutes "thorough" is easier to define, since a costing out study in 2007 concluded that the state's public schools were underfunded by $4.38 billion - and that Philadelphia schools were underfunded by nearly $5,000 per student. More testing has also better quantified achievement gaps.

Smucker says he wants to assure taxpayers that the dollars spent on education are getting results. But the question should be: How much do we need to spend to assure that every student achieves, whatever their circumstances?

Public education is not a commodity, nor is it a government service, like snow removal or garbage collection. Last we checked, no group of taxpayers has ever sued the government to provide more sanitation workers or even police officers. Yet lawsuits for better education funding have been brought in states around the country for decades, with varied results. Clearly, people believe education is so important, it's worth taking the fight to court.

While Smucker should get credit for paying attention to failing schools, it's worth noting that he's part of one of the most expensive legislative bodies in the country. Pennsylvania's General Assembly has a budget of $263 million, that comes out to about $1 million a year per lawmaker. In 2011, the state spent $13,340 per student.