Skip to content

Kada Scott and Malayshia Allford: Two lives lost, two lives remembered

Even those who learned about Kada Scott and Malayshia Allford through the news are grieving the heartbreaking deaths of these beautiful Black girls.

Philadelphia resident Kada Scott, 23, was killed a year ago; Malayshia Allford, 10, was killed in October.

They were beautiful Black girls from Philly.

They were killed in separate incidents that occurred about year apart from each other and at the hands, authorities say, of different perpetrators who had each faced earlier allegations of abuse and mistreatment.

And, in a coincidence that some might attribute to more than happenstance, Wednesday was a day for the City of Sisterly Affection to remember them both.

The deaths of Kada Scott and Malyshia Allford each rocked our city in its own way. Scott was 23 when police said she was killed in October 2025 by an acquaintance who had been charged with kidnapping and assaulting an ex-girlfriend.

Ten-year-old Malayshia, who over the past six years moved through at least three different homes in Philadelphia’s child welfare system, was reported missing last month before police found her remains in the trunk of a car in South Jersey. Her foster mother, who had been previously accused of abusing a 4-year-old foster child, has been charged in connection with her death.

These girls could have been anyone’s sister.

Anyone’s daughter.

Anyone’s baby cousin.

Our city is bleaker without their bright smiles. It’s less vibrant now that their promise has been extinguished. One can only imagine what they would have done with their lives.

On Wednesday, Philadelphians took a moment to honor their brief lives and mourn potential unfulfilled.

The day started out with a protest march to the Department of Human Services from Malayshia’s foster home in the 500 block of North Simpson Street, which is still heavily covered with pink balloons, flowers, stuffed animals, and candles. Social media video shows a small group of demonstrators making their way to Center City carrying heart-shaped pink balloons.

April McBride McGlone, who last week testified before Council about the need to reform, showed up dressed in a pink coat, hat, and glasses. “We’re taking it to the streets today for Malayshia,” she said as she walked behind the group. “Down with DHS.”

When it time for speeches, demonstrators passed around a microphone and shared stories about their experiences with the city agency. “Why are people who are beating kids still foster parents,” one woman asked. Protesters shouted, “Take DHS down” before releasing balloons outside City Hall.

That was followed by her memorial service at the Compassion Connect Venue in West Philly, which was decorated with pink flowers, photos of Malayshia, and pink balloons.

Last month, Pennsylvania State Rep. Andre Carroll introduced a resolution in the general assembly asking that Nov. 18, 2026, be officially declared Kada Scott Day.

On Wednesday at noon, friends and relatives gathered for a brief ceremony outside Ada H. Lewis Middle School at 6199 Ardleigh St. in East Germantown, near where Scott’s body was discovered last year.

Attendees prayed and listened to brief speeches by Carroll, Scott’s father, and Pennsylvania State Sen. Gina H. Curry, who cosponsored a bill that would create an Ebony Alert for missing Black and brown children.

Had she lived, Scott would have turned 25 on Wednesday. Attendees tried to be upbeat by yelling, “Happy birthday, Kada.” But there was no upside to celebrate. Scott’s mother, Kim Matthews, did not attend the gathering. She and her daughter had shared the same birthday.

Carroll, who met Scott four months before she went missing, told me that the Kada Scott Day designation is a way to “redefine her legacy and to take it away from the way that she died.” It puts more of a focus on how she lived.

“The case touched my heart,” he said, before adding, “This is just the start of the conversation.”

The rest of the conversation needs to be ensuring justice is served not just in Scott’s case but in Malayshia’s, as well.

Safeguards need to be put in place to ensure that what the authorities say happened to both girls doesn’t happen to anyone else. Their deaths could have been prevented. But the systems designed to protect Scott and Malayshia failed them.

In Scott’s case, her alleged killer had twice been charged with assaulting an ex-girlfriend, but prosecutors withdrew the charges against Keon King after the victim and witnesses failed to appear in court.

District Attorney Larry Krasner admitted that dropping charges against King for the second incident was a mistake because there was adequate video evidence to have proceeded with the prosecution.

As for Malayshia, her foster mother, Carprice Williams, has been charged in her death. If Williams, a teacher for the Philadelphia School District, is found guilty, the bulk of the blame will lie with her. But it won’t stop there.

Another child had nearly died under Williams’ care a few years earlier. Yet somehow Malayshia ended up in the same home and suffered an even worse fate. She was a ward of the city and was let down by everyone whose job it was to keep her safe.

We can’t fix the what has happened to Scott and Malayshia, but we must do a better job of protecting all of our children.

We owe it to both girls.

About our columnists

In contrast to news reporters, who operate within an independent, nonpartisan framework, columnists are charged with including their perspectives, opinions, and viewpoints when presenting their reporting. Inquirer columnists include Jenice Armstrong, Will Bunch, Luis F. Carrasco, Paul Davies, Daniel Pearson, Trudy Rubin, and Sabrina Vourvoulias.