Skip to content

Commentary: Charter schools can be a solution in public education

THE AUDITOR general's recent report about Philadelphia's charter schools fails to include any empirical data, and is nothing more than political grandstanding based on opinion rather than facts.

THE AUDITOR general's recent report about Philadelphia's charter schools fails to include any empirical data, and is nothing more than political grandstanding based on opinion rather than facts.

The Keystone Alliance believes that Pennsylvania's nearly 20-year-old charter-school law is in need of revisions; however, the auditor general's claim that it is "simply the worst charter-school law in the United States" is ridiculous.

A majority of Pennsylvania's public, brick-and-mortar charter schools serve their intended purpose by providing a safe, high-quality education to students at a cost that's lower than traditional public schools.

Unfortunately, charter-school opponents are either misinformed or intentionally misrepresenting the facts.

On average, brick-and-mortar charter schools perform academically better than the traditional public schools in which their students previously attended, and, more often than not, students who enroll in charter schools often are academically two or three years below their grade level. It takes considerable work to make up for this missed time, but charter schools have proved that they can get the job done.

Over the last 20 years, tens of thousands of parents in Philadelphia have exercised their right of public-school choice and moved their child to a charter school that will meet their needs, while providing a quality education. Students do not have the time to wait for a school district to produce the desired results.

As of the 2013-14 school year, Philadelphia School District's graduation rate was 68 percent. In comparison, in the same time period, the combined graduation rate for all charter schools in the city was 84 percent.

Furthermore, the 2015 Pennsylvania System of School Assessment (PSSA) exams show that charter-school students scored higher than district students in English language arts, math and science. On the 2015 Keystone Exams, charter school students outperformed district students in algebra and literature.

In the content areas of English language arts, science, algebra, literature and biology, charter-school students had a higher academic growth rate than students in district-run schools.

While more work needs to be done, it's apparent that charter schools are working and making a difference.

When considering the cost of the city's charter schools, the district reports that it spends $700 million per year on charter school tuition; however, what's not mentioned is that although the district spends 25 percent of its $2.86 billion budget on charter schools, the 68,000 students enrolled in charter schools account for 34 percent of the district's student population.

In other words, the district spends nearly $13,500 per student who attends a district-run school; each student who attends a charter school receives an average of only $10,470 - 22 percent less. This funding scenario is duplicated in communities across the state, where students who attend charter schools receive 20 percent to 30 percent less funding than their peers in traditional public schools.

It's evident that charter schools are not a financial drain on school districts. Instead of always focusing on funding, perhaps a school district that has a high percent of its student population enrolled in charter schools needs to look internally at its overhead costs and consider rightsizing itself.

While the statewide debate about equitable funding for public school students continues, why are the 100,000 students who attend public brick-and-mortar charter schools always left out of the discussion? Charter-school students deserve access to the same programs, services and funding as their peers in traditional public schools. Parents of charter-school students are taxpayers and they, too, have a right to see that their tax dollars are benefiting their child's education. Parents must retain the ability to have their children educated in a safer learning environment.

We need to move beyond political grandstanding and focus on what is in the best interest of students. Whether a child attends a public charter school or a traditional public school, he or she deserves to have access to high-quality programs and services that will prepare him or her for a successful future. Any public school that continually fails to meet this goal must be forced to close its doors to prevent further academic harm to students.

Tim Eller is executive director of Keystone Alliance for Public Charter Schools.